Skip to content

Does a 33% Payroll Ratio Mean MSP Layoffs?

Not by itself. Bering McKinley's standard keeps service salaries at 33% of service revenue or a little under, and Josh Peterson said a ratio of 37% or 38% next to utilization of only 60% to 65% likely does mean too many people for the work. With healthy utilization, the same ratio more often points to pricing, account management, or unbilled out-of-scope work. For the numbers behind it, see the magic number when calculating your gross profit margin and why agreement gross profits deserve more attention.

In this Roundtable episode, Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, and Gary Boyle, COO and Management Consultant, answer a listener who wrote in that the benchmark "just means fire people."

Does a 33% Payroll Ratio Mean MSP Layoffs?

Not on its own, but it can when the rest of the numbers agree. Bering McKinley's standard is that service salaries stay at 33% of service revenue or a little under. In Gary's example, an MSP bringing in $1,000,000 of service revenue spends about $330,000 on service payroll. Josh calls it the one number he would ask for if he could only see one, because it shows where a business is strong and where it is struggling.

He was also clear that no single metric tells the whole story. Read the ratio next to billable utilization, agreement gross profit, and effective hourly rate. When the ratio sits at 37% or 38% and utilization is only 60% to 65%, Josh said the story gets clear: you likely have to let someone go. When utilization is healthy, the gap is more often on the revenue side, from low-priced managed services deals, thin proactive account management, or out-of-scope work that never gets billed.

  • Treat a high ratio as the start of a diagnosis, not a verdict.
  • Pair it with utilization, agreement gross profit, and effective hourly rate.
  • Low utilization plus a high ratio is the clearest sign of overstaffing.

How Do You Calculate the Service Salaries to Service Revenue Ratio?

Divide the payroll of the people who deliver service by all of your service revenue. Josh counts three kinds of service revenue in an MSP: hourly, project, and recurring. On the payroll side, he counts billable technicians, the dispatcher, and the service manager, along with the payroll taxes on that pay. Gary said many owners can't calculate the ratio at all because of how their books are set up. Most MSPs book every employee's pay as one lump sum below the gross profit line.

Best practice for an MSP, or any service company, is to move service payroll up into cost of goods sold, so revenue minus the cost of delivering service gives a true gross profit. Josh warned that your bookkeeper or accountant may push back, because splitting one payroll number into service and overhead takes a lot of journal entries. Do it anyway. Without that split, you can't see what your service actually costs to run.

  • Count hourly, project, and recurring revenue as service revenue.
  • Include technicians, the dispatcher, and the service manager in service payroll.
  • Move service payroll above the gross profit line in your chart of accounts.

Should an MSP Cut Staff or Raise Prices First?

Start with cash, because your runway decides how long you can wait for the slower fix. Gary looks first at cash flow and the reserves the company has to work with. When both are thin, he said, the answer really is letting someone go, possibly the most expensive person, to buy breathing room to figure out what is happening. The reason is timing. You can't raise prices or cut pay overnight, and Gary said correcting those levers generally takes months, if not a year.

He added that pricing is typically the number one problem, often paired with paying technicians more than the revenue supports. Josh tied the choice to profit. An MSP running at 3% to 5% net profit has accepted low profit, and as he put it, "once you make that mental decision that you won't accept low profit, then you will do the things that you have to do." Then run the math both ways: what would the ratio be with another $5,000 a month of revenue, or $10,000?

  • Check cash flow and reserves before choosing a lever.
  • Expect price and pay corrections to take months, not days.
  • Decide first that low profit is not acceptable, then do the math.

Why Do MSP Owners Keep Extra Technicians on Payroll?

Usually because letting people go is hard and the growth they are waiting for isn't written down. Josh said that when he lays out the facts on this ratio, he has never seen an owner fire anyone based on it. An owner's compassion is real, and it creates a lot of inertia. The reasons he hears sound sensible: projects are coming, a new managed services client is close, and it seems better to be a little overstaffed ahead of growth.

Then he asks for the sales forecast, and there isn't one, or nothing is clearly set to close in the next few months. Underneath is the memory of how much energy it took to hire those people. Gary pointed to the other side of the ratio. Revenue work deserves the same weight as staffing: pipeline work, proposals, projects, and a price increase on your contracts every year. If the answer to all of those is no, he said, "then you have to fire them."

  • Ask for a written sales forecast before holding extra capacity.
  • Give revenue work the same weight as staffing decisions.
  • Raise contract prices every year so payroll doesn't outrun revenue.

Can an MSP's Service Payroll Ratio Be Too Low?

Yes, and it carries its own risk. Gary described a rare case: an MSP with a healthy P&L, strong growth, great agreement gross profit, and a ratio far under the 33% benchmark, with technicians idle for an hour or two a day. The number was correct. The problem was that clients were paying for agreements that weren't being fully delivered, and clients get tired of paying for that over time.

Josh sees this occasionally and asks whether the clients simply have low demand or whether the MSP is missing chances to serve them through account management and proactive work. Both pointed to a simple frame Josh credits to Gary: an MSP is a supply and demand equation. Supply is the number of technicians times the working days in the month times eight hours. Demand is the time your clients actually use. Answering that tells you whether you have a capacity problem or an efficiency problem, because it is going to be one of the two.

  • Read a very low ratio as a warning, not only a win.
  • Fill idle capacity with proactive work for clients you already serve.
  • Compare technician hours available with the hours clients actually use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a 33% payroll ratio mean MSP layoffs?

Not by itself. A ratio above 33% says service payroll is too high for service revenue, but the fix can come from revenue or from payroll. Josh Peterson and Gary Boyle said the case for cutting staff gets clear when the ratio runs high, utilization is low, and cash is short. Otherwise, check pricing, account management, and out-of-scope billing first.

What is a good service salaries to service revenue ratio for an MSP?

Bering McKinley's standard is 33% of service revenue or a little under. Gary Boyle put it simply: an MSP with $1,000,000 in service revenue should spend about $330,000 on service payroll. Read it with billable utilization, agreement gross profit, and effective hourly rate, because one number alone only tells part of the story.

How do you calculate service salaries to service revenue?

Add up payroll for billable technicians, the dispatcher, and the service manager, including payroll taxes, then divide by all service revenue: hourly, project, and recurring. To make that possible, move service payroll out of the single payroll line in overhead and into cost of goods sold, so it sits above the gross profit line.

Is 75% billable utilization realistic for an MSP?

Within a working day, yes, and Bering McKinley's standard is 75% of total work time billable. Over a full year, Gary Boyle said PTO and holidays remove about a month per technician, roughly 8% of the year, so annual numbers often land lower. If your team really runs at 60%, Josh Peterson suggests pricing for the same financial result as 75%.

Should an MSP raise prices or cut staff first?

Pricing is often the root problem, but Gary Boyle said price and pay corrections generally take months, if not a year. If cash flow and reserves are thin, letting someone go may be the only way to buy time to diagnose the rest. A healthier cash position gives you room to correct through pricing and revenue instead.

Can an MSP's service payroll ratio be too low?

Yes. A ratio well under 33% with idle technicians can mean clients are paying for service that isn't being delivered, which builds churn risk over time. Gary Boyle and Josh Peterson suggest comparing your supply of technician hours with what clients actually use, then adding proactive work for clients or adjusting the size of the team.


Listen on Your Favorite Platform

  • Apple Podcasts
  • YouTube
  • YouTube Music
  • Spotify
  • Amazon Music
  • Podbean
  • iHeartRadio
  • Player FM
  • Listen Notes
  • Podchaser
  • BoomPlay

Episode Highlights

  • A listener says the 33% benchmark just means fire people.
  • Why service salaries to service revenue is the one number Josh would pick.
  • Moving service payroll above the gross profit line.
  • How PTO and holidays pull annual utilization below 75%.
  • When thin cash makes a staffing cut the fast lever.
  • Why owners rarely fire anyone off this ratio.
  • Pipeline work, proposals, and annual price increases as the other side of the ratio.
  • When a low ratio signals undelivered service.
  • Treating an MSP as a supply and demand equation.

About the Co-Host: Gary Boyle

Gary Boyle is COO and Management Consultant at Bering McKinley. He ran his own MSP before joining BMK and works with MSP leadership teams on operations, planning, and execution.

About the Host: Josh Peterson

Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.

Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →

Related Resources from Bering McKinley

Want to Continue the Conversation?

Whether your ratio runs high or low, the fix starts with seeing your service costs clearly and deciding what profit you will accept. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.