How Do You Build an MSP Sales Function?
You build an MSP sales function by defining what success looks like before you hire anyone to chase it. On this episode, Josh Peterson notes that the average MSP is about $2 million in revenue and the typical MSP employs zero salespeople, so the owner usually sells by default. Rafi Cohn, who is IntelliComp's entire sales team, won't hire a rep until he can hand that person a blueprint.
In this episode, Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, talks with Rafi about why IT sales is hard, cold calling, building a prospect list, involving engineers in sales, and creative outreach.
How Do You Build an MSP Sales Function?
Start with a blueprint, then hire into it. Rafi joined IntelliComp a little over two years ago as a former customer with no IT background, after the founder decided his own time was better spent running the business than drumming up new deals. Rafi is still the whole sales team, and he has held off hiring on purpose. "I never want to hire somebody unless I can give them the blueprint to success," he said, contrasting it with corporate roles where a rep got a quota and a wish of good luck.
His reasoning is simple: you can't manage someone who misses their numbers if you can't tell them how to hit them. The past two years have been trial and error, tracking opportunities in HubSpot alongside the ticketing system and learning that lead generation, not pipeline tracking, is his main constraint. Josh, who still sells for BMK himself, said he behaves as if a sales manager is reviewing his pipeline, so the records are ready when there are people to manage.
- Write down what success looks like before you hire a rep.
- Track opportunities in a sales tool, not only your ticketing system.
- Sell as if someone will review your pipeline, even when you sell alone.
Why Is Selling Managed IT Services So Hard?
Because most prospects either like their current provider or dread the switch. Rafi came from education staffing, where about 90% of the schools he called had an opening, and the only question was whether to give his firm a chance. In IT, a company with an in-house team or an outsourced provider it likes won't move: "if they're thrilled with their IT company, they're not switching," even if you're cheaper.
When a prospect is unhappy, you still have to time the decision and find the person who makes it, since the office manager may dislike the provider while the CEO is related to it. Rafi recalled a sales leader at another MSP who told his owner never to greet a new rep by announcing that the cycle is long. The upside is retention. One IntelliComp client has been with the firm for more than 20 years, and Rafi argues that a long cycle in should mean a long relationship once you win.
- Expect satisfied clients of other MSPs to stay put, whatever your price.
- Find out who feels the pain and who makes the call.
- Weigh a long sales cycle against how long a won client stays.
Does Cold Calling Still Work for MSPs?
Yes, if the list behind it is right. Josh's view on the episode is that cold calling is "the best thing to sell IT services in 2025," and Rafi agrees it is a useful tool, but "the hardest aspect isn't the actual calling, but it's figuring out the best list." He prefers curating his own list by region, size, and industry over paying thousands of dollars a year for a buyer intent engine, and he connects with the same decision makers on LinkedIn so a missed call isn't a dead end.
Filters have to reflect how buyers actually work. A law firm with 1,000 employees likely has an internal IT team, while a skilled nursing company of the same size, spread across several states, may still need an MSP. Josh pushes owners to justify ranges such as 50 to 100 users, since a 49-user firm and a 99-user firm are very different clients. Rafi also tests different openers, because you can't sell as someone you're not.
- Put your effort into the list before you put it into the dialing.
- Set ideal client filters you can explain, not round numbers.
- Pair calls with LinkedIn and email so one channel isn't the only path.
When Should Engineers Join MSP Sales Calls?
When a qualified prospect needs a specific technical answer, and you should plan for that before it happens. Rafi warns that an owner who knows IT well can get into the weeds too early, offering fixes to someone who isn't paying yet. The first job of a sales conversation is to explain what the MSP does and decide whether the prospect is a fit. Once a prospect's director of IT or CTO asks something detailed, though, you need a technical person ready.
Rafi doesn't want engineers hopping on every sales call, because their time is better spent on clients, but he also knows a new salesperson won't want to feel alone, stuck waiting 48 hours for an answer to a prospect's question. Deciding when and how engineers support sales is part of the infrastructure an owner should build before hiring a rep, the same way some firms split appointment setting from closing.
- Qualify the prospect before you start solving their problems.
- Decide in advance when an engineer joins a sales call.
- Give a new rep a fast path to technical answers.
Does Creative Outreach Work for MSP Sales?
It can start conversations, but don't count on it to close deals. Rafi ran a three-step coffee mailer to 50 or 60 targeted contacts: a handwritten note with a picture of an espresso pod, then an espresso pod in a bubble mailer three days later, then a coffee mug about five days after that, followed by a call to check that the mug arrived. He reached about five people. "How many deals did I close because of that? None," he said.
A different idea, which he credits to Dale Dupree, did better. After a home health prospect went quiet, Rafi dropped off a donut box holding only crumbs, a gift card, and a note apologizing for eating the donuts while waiting to hear back, and the prospect called him. Josh compared the approach to account based selling: working a short list of roughly 20 to 100 good-fit prospects over a long period. For Rafi, the goal of marketing is to stay top of mind until the timing is right.
- Use creative touches to open doors, not to replace a pipeline.
- Follow every mailer with a call or a visit.
- Track the results so you know whether the effort paid off.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you build a sales function for an MSP?
Define the blueprint first: your ideal client, how you generate leads, how you track opportunities, and when technical staff support a sale. Rafi Cohn of IntelliComp, who runs a one-person sales team, won't hire a rep until he can explain how that person will succeed, because you can't manage results you can't describe.
How many salespeople does the average MSP have?
According to Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, the typical MSP employs zero salespeople, and the owner does the selling. Josh puts the average MSP at about $2 million in revenue, with the most common revenue band under $1 million, which is why a dedicated MSP sales manager is so rare.
Are conferences worth it for MSP lead generation?
Often only with a plan. Rafi Cohn knows an MSP that he estimates spends hundreds of thousands of dollars on conferences without a clear return. Before he commits, he talks to someone who has attended, and where clients will be there, he asks them for introductions. Josh Peterson knows an MSP owner who only attends when he is speaking.
Is cold calling still effective for MSPs?
Yes, according to both Josh Peterson and Rafi Cohn on this episode, as long as the list is right. Rafi says the hard part is building a list that matches your ideal client by region, size, and industry, then reaching the same people through LinkedIn and email when the calls don't connect.
Why do MSP sales cycles take so long?
Prospects who like their current IT provider rarely switch, even for a lower price, and unhappy ones still worry about the disruption of a change. Decisions often involve several people with different views. Rafi Cohn notes the payoff: once won, MSP clients can stay for decades, including one IntelliComp client of more than 20 years.
Should engineers go on MSP sales calls?
Only when a qualified prospect needs a specific technical answer. Rafi Cohn advises against pulling engineers into every call, because their time is better spent on clients, but says a salesperson needs quick access to technical help rather than waiting 48 hours. Decide how that works before you hire your first sales rep.
Episode Highlights
- Why the typical MSP has no salespeople at all.
- Building a sales blueprint before hiring the first rep.
- What conferences return for an MSP, and when to speak instead of attend.
- Why IT sales is harder than staffing sales.
- Long sales cycles and a client of more than 20 years.
- Cold calling and the work of building the right list.
- Setting ideal client filters that match how buyers operate.
- When engineers should join a sales conversation.
- A coffee mailer campaign and a box of donut crumbs.
About the Guest: Rafi Cohn
Rafi Cohn is Head of Sales and Marketing at IntelliComp, a Baltimore-based MSP that has been in business for about 30 years. Before joining IntelliComp a little over two years ago, he oversaw sales and marketing at a company outside the IT industry that was an IntelliComp customer. He is IntelliComp's one-person sales team, building the process a future sales hire will follow.
Connect with Rafi on LinkedIn →
About the Host: Josh Peterson
Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.
Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →
Related Resources from Bering McKinley
- To hire or not hire a sales manager for your MSP
- Pairing your sales and service teams together
- Top indicators that your MSP needs a sales consultant
Want to Continue the Conversation?
Whether you still do all the selling yourself or you're ready to hire your first rep, a sales function needs a plan your team can execute. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.
%20logo.png?width=1083&height=200&name=BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png)