Why Should Your MSP Sales Team Role-Play?
Your MSP sales team should role-play because the moments that win or lose a meeting, such as a gatekeeper, an objection, or a prospect's first question, are predictable enough to rehearse. In Josh Peterson's experience, a rep trying to book a first meeting will hear only about five objections, so a team that practices those five out loud stops improvising under pressure. For the bigger picture, see the role of MSP sales consulting in revenue growth and proven techniques for growing monthly recurring revenue.
In this episode, Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, and former MSP owner Ryan Alter talk through how to frame a drill, get past gatekeepers, review a call afterward, and make practice a habit for new and veteran reps alike.
Why Should Your MSP Sales Team Role-Play?
Role-play gives your team a rehearsal for the moments that decide a sale, so the first time a rep faces one isn't the first time they've been there. Josh compared it to military training, where recruits run an obstacle course at night with live fire overhead before they ever face the real thing.
Ryan said that as an MSP owner he used role play well beyond sales: tabletop exercises with clients around a security incident, dispatch drills where he would say "ring ring" and play a client with a problem, and interviews where he handed a candidate a whiteboard marker and asked them to explain the cloud in plain terms. Josh added that technicians, dispatchers, and service managers won't say everything right either if they never practice. He also rehearses new topics out loud, because hearing the words is the quickest way to find the sentence that doesn't make sense.
- Rehearse high-stress sales moments before they happen for real.
- Use role play in dispatch, security planning, and hiring, too.
- Say the words out loud, not just in your head.
How Do You Run a Sales Role-Play That Isn't Awkward?
Start small, separate describing from doing, and put it on the calendar. Josh said that early on, reps tend to tell you what they would say instead of saying it. His fix for a new team is to set the scenario, say who each person is, and run it once with the rep describing their answer while the facilitator holds feedback. Then you flip it and do it for real.
Keep each drill tight: one phase of the sale, one moment in that phase, and one reaction, such as a prospect saying they're happy with their current provider. Josh suggested a gatekeeper objection on Monday and a referral request on Thursday, and said a weekly session that feels hard now could become 20 minutes a day a few months later. Both hosts recommend naming the awkwardness up front. As Josh put it, "It's going to be awkward for you. It's going to be awkward for me."
- Run the scenario once as a description, then do it for real.
- Drill one moment and one reaction per session.
- Schedule practice like a game, and expect it to feel awkward.
Which Sales Objections Should MSP Reps Practice?
Practice the handful of objections you'll hear on nearly every prospecting call. In Josh's experience, a rep trying to book a first meeting will hear only about five. Asked to name some, Ryan listed them quickly: we're happy with our current IT provider, we haven't had any security incidents, our current provider is inexpensive, we've been with them forever, we're busy right now, and we'll look when our contract comes up.
Josh's point was that these came naturally to Ryan because he has lived them, and they won't come naturally to a new rep. Handing a new hire a laptop and business cards and telling them to go sell, without arming them with answers, does them a disservice. Veterans need the same drills. Josh said many seasoned reps land a few big deals a year and mediocre ones the rest, and may repeat something that isn't optimized on every call.
- Write down the five objections your reps hear most.
- Arm new hires with practiced answers before their first calls.
- Hold veteran reps to the same practice schedule.
How Do MSP Salespeople Get Past the Gatekeeper?
Practice the call, but the stronger move is to go around the front desk with a warm introduction. Josh said there are probably hundreds of ways to approach a gatekeeper, and listening to recorded calls shows why so few dials turn into conversations. Ryan described how he approached a new industry where he knew nobody. He asked people he already knew who the key players were and who knew the company he wanted to reach.
Once he had a name, he messaged that person directly instead of calling reception, asked for a few minutes of advice rather than pitching, and then asked who in the industry might be interested and whether they would send an introduction email. He admitted it's slower and said it's worth it. Josh warned that a new rep who only hears this story will try it and fail, because the steps that came naturally to Ryan are missing. Role-play those steps instead.
- Ask your network who knows the company you want to reach.
- Request advice and an introduction, not a meeting.
- Have new reps rehearse the outreach email and the conversation.
What Should You Review After an MSP Sales Call?
Review the call as a short, structured story built on facts, and coach with questions instead of your own script. Josh likes to celebrate that a rep got a stranger to meet with them, then sit down afterward and have the rep tell the story of that meeting without judgment. Those stories can ramble, so he shared an anecdote about a man at a poker tournament who charged players to hear about their losing hands and ended up handing them a laminated sheet listing the facts he needed.
Teach reps to tell the story of the sale the same way. Ryan said that if you catch yourself starting with "what I would have said was," you've lost the thread, because you weren't in the room and you get to say it from the comfort of your own office. He prefers asking, "What if you looked at it this way?" Josh agreed that a sales leader doesn't need all the answers, only the right questions.
- Give reps a short list of facts to report after every meeting.
- Review easy wins too, since they may have left money on the table.
- Coach with questions instead of telling reps what you would have said.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why should MSP sales teams role-play?
Role-play lets reps rehearse predictable, high-stress moments such as a gatekeeper, an objection, or a first meeting before they happen for real. On the episode, Josh Peterson and Ryan Alter describe it as building muscle memory, so a rep's first real encounter with a tough moment isn't the first time they've been there. Practice also helps new and veteran reps alike.
How often should a sales team role-play?
Put it on the calendar and keep each session short. Josh Peterson suggests one narrow drill at a time, such as a gatekeeper objection on Monday and a referral request on Thursday. He says a weekly session that feels hard at first can grow into 20 minutes a day a few months later, once the team has momentum.
Is sales role-play better one-on-one or in a group?
It depends on the goal. Ryan Alter coaches a single objection one-on-one when reps are at different skill levels, and saves larger groups for company-wide scenarios such as a security incident tabletop that can run four hours. Josh Peterson likes a three-person round robin where the observer gives a minute of feedback and nobody gets defensive.
What objections do MSP salespeople hear most?
When booking a first meeting, Josh Peterson expects about five. Ryan Alter's list included being happy with the current IT provider, having had no security incidents, an inexpensive current provider, a long relationship with that provider, being too busy right now, and waiting until the contract comes up. Reps should practice a confident answer to each one.
Do MSP salespeople need to understand the technology?
Not at a technician's level. Ryan Alter recalled a bank president who asked for help making his offices across a wide area feel like one company and did not care about the technical details behind it. The sale was about that outcome. Role-play that keeps reps focused on what the prospect wants builds the confidence new reps often lack.
How should a salesperson open a first sales meeting?
Ask a human question and let the prospect lead. Two openers came up on the episode: asking what's going on in the prospect's world, and asking how they're sleeping and whether they worry about this stuff. Build a bank of first lines, role-play them, and have a third person point out which ones feel awkward or go nowhere.
Episode Highlights
- Using role play for dispatch, client tabletop exercises, and interviews.
- Why reps describe what they would say instead of saying it.
- A bold cold opening tried out at a sales retreat.
- After-action reviews that tell the story of the sale.
- Coaching with questions instead of "what I would have said."
- Going around the gatekeeper with warm introductions.
- The handful of objections reps hear when booking a meeting.
- Why veteran salespeople need practice too.
- Selling outcomes when you don't know the technology.
- Adding surprises once the team trusts the practice.
About the Guest: Ryan Alter
Ryan Alter is a former MSP owner who sold his MSP and joins Josh Peterson as co-host of the Don't Be That Guy series. He has served as CEO of more than one company and, at the time of recording, was starting a new business outside of technology. On the episode, he draws on the role plays he ran with clients, dispatchers, job candidates, and salespeople.
Connect with Ryan on LinkedIn →
About the Host: Josh Peterson
Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.
Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →
Related Resources from Bering McKinley
- Top indicators that your MSP needs a sales consultant
- The role of MSP sales consulting in revenue growth
- MSP consulting services: strategy, operations, and sales
Want to Continue the Conversation?
Practice sticks when your sales goals and the habits behind them are part of a plan your whole team can see. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.
%20logo.png?width=1083&height=200&name=BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png)