Why Do Profitable MSPs Run Out of Cash?
Profitable MSPs run out of cash because profit on paper isn't money in the bank, and many MSPs wait weeks to collect it. Nicholas Reimer of Alternative Payments says MSPs are paid, on industry average, 20 days after an invoice's due date, while growth brings projects that need hardware paid for up front. As Ryan Alter's mentor told him, "a company can be profitable all the way to bankruptcy." To tighten the process, see how to start automating billing and invoicing in ConnectWise Manage and what your numbers are trying to tell you.
In this episode, Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, and co-host Ryan Alter talk with Nicholas Reimer, Partnerships Manager at Alternative Payments, about late payments, card fees, deposits, and the gap between a signed quote and a paid invoice.
Why Do Profitable MSPs Run Out of Cash?
Because profit shows up when you invoice, but you can only spend cash once it lands in the bank. Ryan Alter, who ran his own MSP for 20 years, repeated a mentor's warning that a company can be profitable all the way to bankruptcy, and added, "Your books can say you have all the money, but until it's in the bank, you can't spend it." In Ryan's experience, the risk grows with the business.
A $200,000 MSP mostly bills recurring work, carries a small payroll, and usually gets paid within 15 to 30 days. Once an MSP passes about $1.5 million, it starts taking projects that can approach $500,000, and the owner has to find something like $200,000 for hardware before the client pays. Ryan's MSP also had an audio visual company attached, where he found projects ran about 90% hardware and 10% labor, against roughly half and half in IT, which widened the gap even more.
- Track cash in the bank, not just profit on the P&L.
- Expect cash pressure to rise once projects reach six figures.
- Watch hardware-heavy work, where up-front costs are largest.
How Long Does It Take MSP Clients to Pay Their Invoices?
Longer than most owners think. Nicholas Reimer said that, on industry average, MSPs are paid 20 days after an invoice's due date, which works out to about 36 days after the invoice is created. Alternative Payments works with more than 700 MSPs, and Nicholas said moving clients onto automated billing, ideally with autopay for recurring invoices, can bring that down to three or four days, or even zero.
He described the before and after numbers their operations team tracks: three or four months in, customers are getting paid 40% to 50% faster, and the share of clients paying through the platform rises from about 30% to 60% or 70%. Josh said he sometimes assumes this problem was solved years ago, yet he still finds real AR problems when he starts with a new client. Nicholas's explanation is that many owners started on break fix, moved to recurring revenue, and never updated how they bill.
- Measure how many days past due your invoices are actually paid.
- Put recurring clients on autopay instead of chasing each invoice.
- Revisit any billing process that dates back to break fix.
Should MSPs Pass Credit Card Fees on to Clients?
Most of Alternative Payments' customers do, and Nicholas recommends doing it through choice, not surprise. He said about 90% of their customers pass on the 2.9% card fee. The approach is to offer options: pay by card and cover the 2.9% fee, shown up front instead of on the last checkout screen; pay by ACH at no charge; or, for specific cases, finance the bill over several months while the MSP gets paid right away.
Nicholas said only a very small percentage of clients use financing, but having it available is a value add when a big equipment upgrade comes up. Ryan took a different route at his MSP. He started with checks only because he didn't want to pay the 3%, and when the market pushed him to accept cards, he gave a cash discount on invoices so clients could choose. Either way, clients see the cost and make the call.
- Offer card, ACH, and financing, and show any fee up front.
- Let clients choose between convenience and cost.
- Present financing as a value add for big projects.
How Do You Close the Gap Between a Signed Quote and Getting Paid?
Capture payment details at the moment the client signs, not later. Nicholas calls the target a quote to cash model: the client signs the quote, their payment details are captured, recurring payments are scheduled, the PSA feeds the accounting system, and each payment is reconciled back to both. Josh shared a time Bering McKinley missed that step. The proposal had no payment link, the setup link came later with the first invoice from ConnectWise, the client never clicked it, and nothing alerted the team.
The balance grew to $60,000 before BMK pressed for payment, and then it became a fight. The fix was embedding a payment link in the first invoice and treating that payment as the trigger to launch the engagement. Nicholas compared it to a sales process, where every unneeded break between steps gives the buyer a chance to change their mind and kills momentum.
- Collect payment details when the quote is signed.
- Alert someone when a new client hasn't set up payment.
- Make the first payment the trigger to start the work.
How Should MSPs Use Deposits and Lines of Credit?
Use deposits to cover hardware, and have credit lined up before you need it. Ryan said his MSP started asking for down payments that would normally cover the hardware portion of a job up front, so the business wasn't sending out that much cash. He also warned that bankers sometimes forget to renew a line of credit, and a renewal can take 30 days, right when you need to order half a million dollars in hardware.
Ryan keeps relationships with two or three financial institutions so he can shop around for credit. Banks put significant attention on accounts receivable, he said. On about $200,000 a month in invoicing, a couple thousand dollars of slippage is normal, but a lender doesn't want to see $50,000 or $60,000 sitting at 180 days. The sooner you collect, the sooner you can pay the bank, and that is what lenders look for.
- Ask for a deposit that covers the hardware on large projects.
- Check renewal dates on your lines of credit well ahead of time.
- Keep aged receivables low before you ask a bank for credit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do profitable MSPs run out of cash?
Profit is recorded when you invoice, but cash only counts once it is in the bank. When clients pay weeks late and growth brings projects that need hardware bought up front, a profitable MSP can still miss payroll. Ryan Alter's mentor summed it up: a company can be profitable all the way to bankruptcy.
How many days late do MSP clients pay invoices?
According to Nicholas Reimer of Alternative Payments, MSPs are paid on industry average 20 days after an invoice's due date, or about 36 days after the invoice is created. He said automating collection, ideally with autopay on recurring invoices, can bring that down to three or four days, and sometimes to zero.
Do MSPs pass credit card fees to clients?
Many do. Nicholas Reimer said about 90% of Alternative Payments' MSP customers pass on the 2.9% card fee. He recommends offering choices, with card fees shown up front, ACH at no charge, and financing for specific cases, so clients decide between convenience and cost instead of finding a surprise fee at checkout.
What does quote to cash mean for an MSP?
It means the client's signature on a quote starts the whole payment process. Payment details are captured right away, recurring payments are scheduled, the PSA feeds the accounting system, and each payment is reconciled back to both. The goal is to remove the gaps where a new client can sign and never set up payment.
Should an MSP collect a deposit on hardware projects?
In Ryan Alter's experience, yes. His MSP started asking for down payments that would normally cover the hardware portion of a job, so it wasn't funding the client's equipment with its own cash. That matters most on large projects, where hardware can run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Should MSP client onboarding include billing setup?
Josh Peterson suggests it should. The onboarding templates he has seen rarely include a step to confirm the agreement is set up and the payment portal is configured and complete. Ryan Alter said onboarding was never an area his MSP felt it had mastered, and that MSPs often struggle to charge much for it.
Episode Highlights
- Why a company can be profitable all the way to bankruptcy.
- MSPs getting paid 20 days past the due date on average.
- Offering card, ACH, and financing with fees shown up front.
- Not letting a few check-only clients set AR policy for everyone.
- Lines of credit, deposits, and hardware-heavy projects.
- Vendor sprawl and keeping license costs reconciled.
- A $60,000 receivable that started with a missing payment link.
- The bookkeeper who withdrew every employee's paycheck.
- Making payment setup part of client onboarding.
About the Guest: Nicholas Reimer
Nicholas Reimer is the Partnerships Manager at Alternative Payments, which automates accounts receivable for MSPs with ACH, card payments, and financing. He said the company works with more than 700 MSPs across the US and recently opened in Canada. His day-to-day work centers on the company's referral program, and he brings a small business background to how he thinks about cash flow.
Connect with Nicholas on LinkedIn →
About the Host: Josh Peterson
Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.
Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →
Related Resources from Bering McKinley
- Recurring revenue in ConnectWise: set up agreements that don't break later
- Client engagement strategy for MSPs, from onboarding to QBRs
- Solving common profitability challenges with MSP financial services
Want to Continue the Conversation?
Cash flow problems usually start as process gaps your leadership team can close. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.
%20logo.png?width=1083&height=200&name=BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png)