Skip to content

Why Can't MSP Owners Let Go of Sales?

MSP owners hold on to sales because selling is what they already do well, but scaling takes a second skill, sales management, that most owners never set out to learn. Trevor Dierdorff, who started an MSP in 1998 as a side hustle, said none of the salespeople hired over the years worked out, and when asked about investing in becoming a good sales manager, Trevor's honest answer was no. For more on that shift, see how to decide whether your MSP should hire a sales manager and why pairing your sales and service teams pays off.

In this episode, Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, talks with Trevor about owner-led sales, why first sales hires fail, how culture shapes a new seller's odds, and building trust with prospects before asking for the business.

Why Can't MSP Owners Let Go of Sales?

Most owners can't let go because selling is the part of the job they already do well, and handing it off means learning a different profession. Josh opened the episode by saying owner-led sales is sometimes a necessary stage, but when it becomes the MSP's strategy, Josh sees it as owners choosing not to try to master sales management. Trevor agreed that sales and sales management are completely different skills, and compared promoting a strong seller into management to making a great elementary school teacher a principal.

Josh described two versions of owner-led sales. In the first, the owner decides no one else can sell like the owner, so no one else will. In the second, the owner sells only until the business can bring in someone who can replicate the work and eventually do it better. Trevor got into the business for the technology, not for sales, and described many MSP owners as accidental entrepreneurs.

  • Decide on purpose which version of owner-led sales you are running.
  • Treat sales management as its own profession with its own skills.
  • Use owner-led selling as a bridge to a sales team, not a permanent plan.

Why Do an MSP's First Sales Hires Fail?

They usually fail because the owner hands over a pitch that only works for the owner, then never manages the seller's activity. Trevor found both causes through trial and error. Prospects buy differently from a salesperson than from the CEO, so teaching a rep the owner-to-owner conversation didn't work. And while Trevor's techs were held to real-time time entry and ticket notes, salespeople were out in the field with no comparable accountability. Josh agreed that the owner's halo is real, and said the fix is managing the activities more than the person.

The hardest step, in Josh's view, is studying what the owner actually owes a new seller and how to take them from rookie to good, instead of falling into the trap of "I hired you, now go sell." A new hire should first aid the owner's selling, then work up to selling alone. Josh noted that sales management is a profession people spend whole careers mastering, so owners rarely get it right by luck.

  • Give a new seller a repeatable process, not an imitation of the owner.
  • Track sales activity the way you track technician time and tickets.
  • Plan a ramp where the new hire supports the owner's deals first.

How Should an MSP Plan for Client Attrition?

Plan for it by forecasting how much you must sell just to replace the clients you will lose. Trevor's MSP had five of its top seven clients acquired between 2022 and 2024, which left a large gap to refill. Josh said an event like that isn't perfectly predictable, but a sales-driven MSP does a meaningful forecasting exercise: what is our historical attrition rate, how much do we have to sell to beat it, and are there market conditions that suggest attrition could be greater?

That step often gets skipped. Josh said it matters in a different way without a sales force, but once you have one, it gives clarity on the quota and the expectations for every seller. Trevor also shared a hopeful note: the team later closed five new clients in six weeks. They were smaller than the ideal client profile but fit the capacity the team had, a reminder that pipeline can move faster than expected once the work starts.

  • Know your historical attrition rate before you set a sales target.
  • Ask whether market conditions, such as client acquisitions, raise that risk.
  • Use the attrition forecast to set quota and expectations for sellers.

How Does Company Culture Affect a New MSP Salesperson?

A strong, intentional culture gives a new seller one less battle to fight. Josh said most companies claim a good or great culture, but real culture shows in the time, money, and intention behind it. Trevor greets the technicians every morning with "Good morning, superheroes," and the team works in the office together, because Trevor sees the conversations between tickets and in-person escalations as how techs grow. Trevor also said seeing the team deliver exceptional service gives a salesperson belief in the offer.

A new seller doesn't have to be like everyone else, just complementary: in Trevor's words, culture is a recipe, and you don't put chocolate chips in your beef stew. Josh warned that in a poor culture, where people are protective and sales versus service starts on day zero, owners fight hard to overcome that inertia. Years ago, Trevor's MSP lost its largest client because the team was dysfunctional, and Trevor took the blame, saying, "You can't delegate company culture."

  • Build culture on purpose; prospects and recruits can see it quickly.
  • Hire for attitude and complementary fit, not sameness.
  • Fix culture at the top, because only the owner can.

How Can an MSP Build Trust With Prospects Before Selling?

Create regular encounters where you add value without pitching, then be intentional about asking for the business. Trevor is hosting a new interview series where identified prospects work through a business crisis scenario on camera, and is relaunching an invitation-only executive breakfast where service providers aren't in the room unless they serve on the board or sponsor. Both are meant to build know, like, and trust.

Trevor admitted relying too much on prospects thinking of the MSP first when a need came up, instead of saying, "I'd really love the opportunity to earn your business." That matters because, in Trevor's experience, a business will leave its bank, CPA, or attorney before its IT provider, since buyers who aren't IT experts fear making a bad decision. Josh pushed for measuring it: what share of guests lead to a prospecting call, and how many of those reach a proposal. A salesperson, Josh suggested, could feed the top of that funnel.

  • Add value in settings where prospects aren't being sold to.
  • Ask for the chance to earn the business instead of waiting to be remembered.
  • Measure how trust-building activities turn into calls and proposals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why can't MSP owners let go of sales?

Selling is usually the owner's strongest skill, and handing it off means learning sales management, a separate profession. On the BMK Vision Podcast, Josh Peterson said owner-led sales can be a necessary stage, but making it the MSP's long-term strategy means choosing not to learn sales management. Trevor Dierdorff agreed that the two skills are completely different.

What is the difference between sales and sales management?

Sales is finding opportunities and closing them. Sales management is building the process, coaching reps from rookie to good, and holding them accountable to their activities. Trevor Dierdorff compared promoting a strong seller into management to making a great teacher a principal: a different job that takes real study to do well.

Why do MSP salespeople fail?

Often the cause is the setup, not the hire. Trevor Dierdorff found that teaching reps the owner's own pitch didn't work, because prospects buy differently from a CEO, and that salespeople lacked the activity accountability technicians had. Josh Peterson added that owners need to plan a ramp that takes a new seller from rookie to good.

How do you hold an MSP salesperson accountable?

Manage the activities more than the person. Trevor Dierdorff pointed out that techs are held to real-time time entry and ticket notes, while salespeople in the field often aren't held to anything similar. Josh Peterson suggested tying expectations to a forecast of attrition and how much the team must sell to beat it.

How does company culture affect MSP sales hires?

A cohesive, intentional culture keeps a new seller from walking into a sales versus service fight. Trevor Dierdorff said seeing the team deliver strong service gives a salesperson belief in the offer, and that a new hire doesn't have to be like everyone else. They just have to be complementary to the team.

Why are businesses slow to switch IT providers?

In Trevor Dierdorff's experience, a business will leave its bank, CPA, or attorney before its IT provider, because buyers who aren't IT experts are afraid of making a bad decision. Many stay with a mediocre provider until they feel real pain, which makes building know, like, and trust ahead of time especially important.


Listen on Your Favorite Platform

  • Apple Podcasts
  • YouTube
  • YouTube Music
  • Spotify
  • Amazon Music
  • Podbean
  • iHeartRadio
  • Player FM
  • Listen Notes
  • Podchaser
  • BoomPlay

Episode Highlights

  • Why sales and sales management are separate professions.
  • The two versions of owner-led sales.
  • Turning a 1998 side hustle into a full-time MSP.
  • Why teaching reps the owner's pitch backfires.
  • Managing sales activity the way you manage technician time.
  • Forecasting attrition after losing top clients to acquisitions.
  • Building culture on purpose, starting with "Good morning, superheroes."
  • Hiring for complementary fit instead of sameness.
  • Building trust with prospects through interviews and executive breakfasts.

About the Guest: Trevor Dierdorff

Trevor Dierdorff is the founder and CEO of Amnet, a managed service provider in Colorado. Trevor started Amnet in 1998 as a side hustle while working as a PC technician, after an earlier career in telecom sales, and made it a full-time business in 2000. Trevor puts a strong focus on an intentional, in-office company culture.

Connect with Trevor on LinkedIn →

About the Host: Josh Peterson

Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.

Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →

Related Resources from Bering McKinley

Want to Continue the Conversation?

If owner-led sales has become your MSP's ceiling, building a sales function starts with a plan your whole team can execute. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.