Skip to content

How Much of Your MSP's Success Is Luck?

Probably more than you think, and the fix is to treat every decision as a bet you can improve. Bob Coppedge, CEO of Simplex-IT, recalled a CompTIA industry review in which about 40% of MSP owners called themselves savvy business people, and he suspects many of them, himself included, are fooling themselves about how much was skill and how much was timing. For more on staying ahead of change, see how to future-proof your MSP for the next wave of technological change and how to build an MSP marketing strategy that delivers leads.

In this episode of From the Trenches, Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, talks with Bob about luck and poker, the model year program Simplex-IT uses to keep clients current, and how AI search is changing the case for MSP video content.

How Much of Your MSP's Success Is Luck?

More than most owners admit, which is why your process matters more than any single result. Bob pointed to Thinking in Bets by Annie Duke, which argues that business is less like chess, with a finite set of moves and one shared objective, and more like poker. As Bob put it, you “could play the best strategy possible, statistically speaking, and lose,” and you may never know which it was.

Josh, who calls poker one of his great passions, compared it to game theory optimal play, where strong players review every hand afterward, win or lose. He asks clients the same question about deals: was it luck that you closed that one when the sales process sounded weak? Owners who can face that answer improve the process; owners who can’t keep repeating odd mistakes. Bob’s summary: “Every act that you do towards a goal only nudges the needle of probability.” The self-made success story and the “I’m a failure” story both ignore that.

  • Judge a decision by the process behind it, not one outcome.
  • Review won deals as hard as lost ones.
  • Expect variance and keep improving your odds over many decisions.

Why Can't an MSP Win by Being Cheaper Than Internal IT?

Because an internal IT team is rarely what you replace anymore. Bob said many MSPs started when companies employed full-time IT staff they weren’t getting full value from, so the pitch was easy: cheaper and better at keeping the lights on. “Usually we’re replacing another MSP at this point,” he said, which leaves two choices: be cheaper than the other MSP, or show the value you drive for the business.

Bob, who says he hates commoditization, started his MSP in 2007 as a former CIO focused on improving clients’ businesses, not just fixing blinking lights. Josh saw the same pattern in an owner he works with, a former CIO who bought into the industry a few years ago and has accelerated past MSPs that have been around for 10 to 15 years. In Josh’s view, that owner arrived without the scar tissue of tools and client demands and with one focus: helping businesses get better.

  • Assume you are replacing another MSP, not an internal IT team.
  • Lead with business outcomes, not the tool stack.
  • Bring a CIO’s lens to every client conversation.

How Should an MSP Prepare Clients for Constant Change in IT?

Tell clients up front that IT changes every year, and build a cadence around it. Bob sees a revolution in IT every two or three years, and he named the last three big shifts as big data, security, and AI, each about three to five years apart and each driven by information rather than hardware. That gives many IT people a steep learning curve, because, as he put it, they “were brought up on T. We were not brought up on I.”

Simplex-IT’s answer is its model year program, which began with model year 22. Like car models, each year has a defined package: in September, Bob was selling model year 25, finalizing 26, and already sketching ideas for 27. Clients hear at the start that an upgrade comes every year, and “if you want to, you can stay on your current model year for a couple of years.” Josh liked that it sets the expectation before change frustrates the client.

  • Expect a major shift in IT every few years.
  • Package each year’s improvements so clients know what’s coming.
  • Set the upgrade expectation at the start of the relationship.

How Does AI Search Change MSP Marketing?

It rewards content that answers real questions instead of matching keywords. Bob explained that a traditional web search breaks a query into words and points you to websites, which he compared to billboards on a highway, while “AI wants to answer your question.” By his estimate, around 17% to 20% of people search only with AI, and roughly half or more use it some of the time.

That is why Simplex-IT posts its YouTube videos and their scripts on its website, where they can be crawled. Bob added a second shift: by his count, over 60% of business decision makers are Millennials or younger, and they want to see what you have and then be left alone, not touched seven times. He also said early MSP marketing leaned on two messages, how impressive our services are and how exposed you are without us, and that you “can’t just sell fear, uncertainty, and doubt.”

  • Answer the questions buyers actually ask.
  • Publish video scripts on your website so they can be found.
  • Replace fear-based messages with how you help clients succeed.

How Can an MSP Start Making Videos Without a Big Team?

Start with one client question, a short AI-drafted script, and simple cut edits. Simplex-IT follows the They Ask, You Answer approach and has made about 600 videos over three or four years, with a Trello board holding 30 to 40 future topics. For owners who haven’t started, Bob’s process is simple. When Microsoft announces a change your clients should know about, ask Copilot for a casual 30 to 60 second script, adjust it to sound like you, and record one paragraph at a time so an editor can cut between them.

You only have to get each paragraph right once. Before he had staff for video, Bob hired editors on Fiverr, kept two at a time, and asked them to match an earlier video. Why don’t more owners do it? Most techs don’t like public speaking. Bob’s answer: “You just have to make a couple more than your competition.”

  • Turn every client question into a video idea.
  • Use AI for a first-draft script, then make it your own.
  • Aim for consistency, not studio production.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is MSP success luck or skill?

Both. Bob Coppedge argues that business works more like poker than chess: you can make the right decision and still lose. Skill is the process you control, and every action only nudges the odds. Review wins and losses the same way, and ask whether luck closed a deal your process didn’t earn.

Why do MSP owners overestimate their business skills?

Partly because early success came easily. Bob Coppedge recalled a CompTIA review where about 40% of MSP owners called themselves savvy business people, and he believes many overrate their grasp of cash flow, payables, receivables, HR, and constant improvement. Some don’t see how much timing helped when replacing underused internal IT made the pitch simple.

What is a model year program for an MSP?

It is an annual package of improvements, named like car models. Simplex-IT started with model year 22 and starts selling each new model year as the calendar year turns. Clients learn at the start that an upgrade comes every year, and they can stay on their current model year for a couple of years if they choose.

How does AI search affect MSP marketing?

AI tools try to answer a question rather than list websites that match keywords. Bob Coppedge estimates that 17% to 20% of people search only with AI. MSPs that publish videos and transcripts answering real client questions give those tools content to draw from, without spending a lot of money.

How do I write a script for an MSP video?

Start with something your clients need to know, such as an upcoming Microsoft change. Bob Coppedge asks Copilot for a casual 30 to 60 second script, edits it so it sounds like him, then records one paragraph at a time. Cut edits mean you only need each paragraph right once.

How many videos should an MSP make?

Fewer than you might think. Bob Coppedge says you only need to make a couple more than your competition. Simplex-IT has made about 600, but it started with a simple format: an introduction, a few bullet points, a conclusion, and a call to action, edited by freelancers working from an example.


Listen on Your Favorite Platform

  • Apple Podcasts
  • YouTube
  • YouTube Music
  • Spotify
  • Amazon Music
  • Podbean
  • iHeartRadio
  • Player FM
  • Listen Notes
  • Podchaser
  • BoomPlay

Episode Highlights

  • Why business is more like poker than chess.
  • The CompTIA finding that about 40% of MSP owners call themselves business savvy.
  • Why MSPs now replace other MSPs, not internal IT.
  • Big data, security, and AI as information shifts, not technology shifts.
  • How Simplex-IT’s model year program sets client expectations.
  • Why AI search rewards content that answers questions.
  • Marketing to Millennial decision makers without seven touches.
  • Writing a video script with AI and recording with cut edits.
  • Why most MSPs agree with video content but never start.

About the Guest: Bob Coppedge

Bob Coppedge is CEO of Simplex-IT, a managed and co-managed IT services provider serving Cleveland, Akron, and Northeast Ohio, which he started in 2007. He has worked in IT since about 1978, including time as a CIO and as a database and general consultant. Bob is a graduate of Second City in Cleveland, ran an improv group for about 15 years, and has written a couple of books.

Connect with Bob on LinkedIn →
Visit Simplex-IT →

About the Host: Josh Peterson

Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.

Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →

Related Resources from Bering McKinley

Want to Continue the Conversation?

Owners who treat each decision as a bet build processes that improve their odds year after year. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.