Should Your Accountant Design Your MSP's P&L?

No. Your accountant is the right partner for clean books, accurate cash records, and a smooth tax season, but the way your P&L is structured should serve how you run your MSP, not how tax work gets done fastest. You are the one responsible for the P&L and the one who uses it all year, so you decide how it is built. If you want the numbers that structure should support, start with the gross profit margin target BMK uses for MSPs and the costs MSPs often forget to count before declaring a profit.
This post covers where your accountant's job and your job as an owner differ, why service salaries belong above the line, which BMK targets depend on that structure, and how to make the change while keeping a good working relationship with your accountant.
Should Your Accountant Design Your MSP's P&L?
Your accountant should not be the one who decides how your P&L is organized, even though they should absolutely keep it accurate. When an accountant comes into a business, it is natural for them to set things up in a format that helps them do their job. That can mean grouping payroll, income, and expense lines in whatever way lets them gather information quickly and deliver results on time. From their seat, that makes complete sense.
The problem is that a structure built for tax and compliance work is not always a structure built for managing an MSP. You need to see what it costs to deliver service, how much each revenue stream contributes, and whether the business is converting revenue into profit. Out of respect for your accountant, you may be tempted to defer to their preferences. Resist that. The P&L is your management tool, and it has to be organized so you can read it and act on it every month, not only once a year.
- Your accountant keeps the books accurate; you decide how they are organized.
- A layout that speeds up tax work can hide how your MSP really performs.
- Own the P&L because you are the one who uses it all year.
What Does an Accountant Do Best for an MSP?
An accountant does their best work keeping your financial records organized, keeping track of your cash, and getting the business ready for tax season. Every MSP should have an accountant within reach for exactly those reasons, and you should lean on them for what they are trained to do. Accountants and CPAs are skilled professionals, and that skill is the reason you can ask for a structure that fits your business.
A well-trained accountant can work from almost any reasonable account layout and still produce what the tax return and the compliance calendar require. The point is not that accountants are doing anything wrong. It is that their goals and yours are different. Their goal is accurate records and timely filings. Your goal is a business that delivers service profitably and grows. Both goals matter, and both can be met from the same set of books when the owner sets the structure and the accountant keeps it accurate.
- Use your accountant for bookkeeping accuracy, cash tracking, and tax readiness.
- Their goal is accurate records; your goal is a profitable, growing MSP.
- One set of books can serve both when you set the structure.
Where Do Service Salaries Belong on an MSP's P&L?
Service salaries belong above the line, in cost of goods sold, because they are the cost of delivering the services you sell. In general accounting it is often easier and faster to put all payroll together in one place, below the line with the rest of your operating expenses. That works for filing, but it hides your service delivery cost, which is one of the most important things an MSP owner needs to see.
BMK's Combined Gross Profit Margin standard counts service payroll for technicians, dispatchers, and managers as a service cost. BMK's Service Salary to Service Revenue standard measures that cost directly: service payroll plus payroll taxes, divided by total service revenue, where service revenue is recurring, project, and hourly billable revenue combined. The target is 33% of service revenue. It is the largest service cost an MSP carries, and missing it makes BMK's target of 55% gross profit for the service department very hard to reach.
- Put technician, dispatcher, and service manager payroll in cost of goods sold.
- Service salary to service revenue is service payroll plus payroll taxes over service revenue.
- BMK's target for that ratio is 33% of service revenue.
Which BMK Targets Depend on a Clean P&L?
BMK's most important financial target, a combined gross profit margin of 42% of total revenue, only means something if your P&L puts each cost in the right place. Combined gross profit margin is what remains after the direct costs of all your products and services, including service payroll, product costs, and resold cloud costs. BMK sets aside 15% of revenue for general and administrative expenses and 10% of revenue for sales expenses.
Take that 25% away from a 42% gross margin and you land at BMK's 17% net profit target. BMK's standard is blunt about what this requires: to get an accurate read on gross profit margin, your bookkeeping and categorization hygiene must be very high. If your number is far above 42%, check whether costs that belong in service, product, or cloud are sitting down in general and administrative expenses. If it is far below, check whether cost of goods sold is carrying items that belong below the line.
- BMK's combined gross profit margin target is 42% of total revenue.
- 15% general and administrative plus 10% sales leaves a 17% net profit.
- A number far above or below 42% usually points to a categorization problem.
How Do You Restructure Your P&L Without Straining the Relationship?
You restructure your P&L by deciding what you need to see, explaining it to your accountant, and asking them to keep the books accurate inside that structure. Start with the categories that matter most to an MSP: service costs above the line, revenue separated by type, and operating expenses below the line. Then walk your accountant through the purpose behind each change, so the request reads as a management need rather than a criticism of their work.
Will this make their job a little more involved? Possibly. That tradeoff is worth it, because a trained professional can still get their work done no matter how the accounts are organized, and you gain a P&L you can run the business from. Once the structure is set, use it. BMK's P&L Review standard calls for a consistent time each month to review trends, net profit, product sales, and overall gross profit margin, and to check those numbers against service department performance and agreement gross profit.
- Decide what you need to see, then explain the structure to your accountant.
- A slightly more involved job for your accountant is a fair trade for usable numbers.
- Review the P&L at the same time every month once it is set up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should my accountant design my MSP's P&L?
Your accountant should keep your P&L accurate, but you should decide how it is structured. Accountants naturally organize the books in a way that makes their own work fast, which suits tax and compliance. An MSP owner needs a layout that shows service delivery cost and gross profit clearly, so the owner should set the structure and the accountant should maintain it.
Are technician salaries cost of goods sold for an MSP?
Yes. Technician pay is the cost of delivering the services you sell, so it belongs above the line in cost of goods sold. BMK's Combined Gross Profit Margin standard counts service payroll for technicians, dispatchers, and service managers as service cost. Grouping it with all other payroll below the line hides what your service delivery really costs.
What is a good gross profit margin for an MSP?
BMK's target is a combined gross profit margin of 42% of total revenue, after the direct costs of service, product, and resold cloud. With 15% of revenue for general and administrative expenses and 10% for sales expenses, a 42% margin leaves BMK's 17% net profit target. The number is only reliable if costs are categorized correctly.
How do you calculate service salary to service revenue?
Add service payroll and payroll taxes, then divide by total service revenue, which combines recurring, project, and hourly billable revenue. BMK's target is 33% of service revenue. It is the largest service cost an MSP carries, and missing it makes BMK's 55% service department gross profit target very hard to reach, so measure it monthly.
How often should an MSP owner review the P&L?
Review it every month at a consistent time. BMK's P&L Review standard calls for looking at trends and targets, including net profit, product sales, and overall gross profit margin. It also calls for checking the P&L against service department performance and agreement gross profit, so problems are diagnosed from more than one source before you act.
Can I change my P&L structure without upsetting my accountant?
Usually, yes. Explain what you need to see and why, such as service costs above the line and revenue separated by type. Accountants are trained professionals who can work from any reasonable layout and still meet tax and compliance needs. The change may add a little to their work, but it gives you numbers you can manage from.
Related Resources from Bering McKinley
- What your numbers are trying to tell you about your business
- How business performance analysis drives budgeting and forecasting
- Why agreement gross profit deserves more of your attention
Want to Continue the Conversation?
A P&L built for running your MSP is only useful if someone reviews it every month. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.
%20logo.png?width=1083&height=200&name=BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png)