How Detailed Should MSP Action Items Be?
An MSP action item should be sized to about a week of work for one person, with an hour estimate for the whole task, not a separate line for every step inside it. Josh Peterson once gave a client leader roughly 30 action items for a single initiative goal and heard that the detail felt like distrust, and Gary Boyle's view is that 30 weekly items in one month is simply too itemized. For the bigger picture, see how Bering McKinley approaches organizational strategic planning for business performance and translating business goals into performance targets.
In this BMK Vision Roundtable episode, Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, and Gary Boyle, COO and Management Consultant, talk through how much detail an action item needs, why plans drift, and how to tell whether a plan is working.
How Detailed Should MSP Action Items Be?
Detailed enough to describe about a week of work with an honest hour estimate, and no more. Gary laid out the layers of a plan: a yearly strategic plan, quarterly initiatives, monthly goals under those, and weekly action items. In Vision, action items are the weekly tasks an employee or consultant completes to reach the goal set for the month. So when Josh gave one leader about 30 action items against a single initiative goal to improve agreement gross profit, from running the report to fixing it to cleaning up work roles and work types, Gary sided with the client. That many items in one month is too itemized. The person needs a task, not every single step and every next move. Josh called it good feedback. His reason for the long list was to make sure the weekly meeting is never empty, while stopping short of something like 10 hours due every week.
- Size each action item to roughly a week of work for one person.
- Estimate hours for the whole task instead of listing every step.
- Treat a long list against one goal as a sign that steps became action items.
When Should You Break an Action Item Into Steps?
Break it into steps when the person doing the work doesn't yet know the subject well enough to estimate it. Gary calls this the inflection point: are you creating an action item for each step, or creating the task that takes about a week and estimating the hours for the whole thing? There is no hard and fast rule, he said. It depends on where the client is in their knowledge of the subject and how prepared the consultant is to provide documentation or guidance. Josh described starting very deep, all the way down to "sit down at your desk," and using those steps to build a realistic view of how long the work will take, so the plan doesn't underestimate it and set the team up to fail. After that, he moves the client to the highlight reel: run the report and fix what's broken, identify agreement gross profit for that group of clients and form a view on why, then remediate the top five offenders.
- Match the detail to the person's experience with the work.
- Use a full step list early to build an honest time estimate.
- Collapse the steps into a few weekly tasks once the estimate is clear.
How Do You Keep Action Items Tied to Your Strategic Plan?
Make every action item trace back to a larger goal, and rank the work instead of piling it on. Josh said that when he logs into the tools clients use, their lists often show real thought, but there is no linkage between the action items and a larger goal. Teams end up stringing together enough tactics to get some outcome without really knowing why they are doing the work. That is part of why Josh loads up the plan: he wants people too busy to chase the next great idea that pops into their heads. Gary wasn't sure whether that approach helps or hurts. His test is to ask what the one thing is, and whether you have 10 things that are kind of the one thing, or one of those 10 that truly is the one thing. Too many action items gets confusing, and so does jamming a pile of steps into one item. His answer is to prioritize and time bind the work, so whatever is next and highest priority gets done first.
- Trace every action item to a monthly goal, an initiative, and the yearly plan.
- Rank the work so the next priority is always clear.
- Put a time bound on each item so the plate fills by priority, not volume.
Why Do Strategic Plans Drift Away From Their Goals?
Plans drift because new work keeps getting added to the weekly meeting, and each addition seems reasonable on its own. Gary said the weekly and monthly cadence is the right approach, whether you meet with your consultant or internally with your leadership team, as long as a true yearly plan sits behind it. The plan is what sets up the meetings. The trouble starts when teams create other action items, tasks, or even initiatives during the year and add them to those meetings. We need to do this in order to do that. This was a really good idea, so add another item. Bit by bit, the team drifts further from its goals and out of alignment. Gary's advice is to stay focused on what you decided six months ago in your big planning session. Josh described how the review layers help: one weekly meeting becomes the monthly meeting, where you review financials and initiative goals, and one becomes the quarterly meeting, where you ask whether you chose the right initiatives.
- Keep the weekly meeting focused on the plan's own action items.
- Make new ideas earn a place instead of joining the agenda by default.
- Use monthly and quarterly reviews to check whether you chose the right work.
How Can You Tell if Your MSP's Plan Is Working?
Give the plan a year, measure it against targets, and ask whether you can tie the results to what you actually did. Josh's concern is that a team can fool itself, so the real question is whether the world simply served up a good quarter or whether your actions produced the result. Gary described a client who is still deep in the business and loose on formal planning. Graded against the book, Gary gave the process a C plus or a B minus, yet he called the results an A plus, because the owner kept meeting, kept looking at the numbers, and made the big decisions at the right time. What helped most was targets: knowing what gross profit should look like and what revenue to expect from each new hire. Gary's broader point is that time horizons are too short. Set a plan for a year, follow it even when it feels like going through the motions, and check back. Josh pointed to the old saying that the more prepared you are, the luckier you get.
- Judge a plan over a year, not a month.
- Set targets first so you can tell a working plan from a lucky quarter.
- Do some planning consistently rather than waiting to do it perfectly.
Frequently Asked Questions
How detailed should action items be in a strategic plan?
Each action item should describe about a week of work for one person, with an hour estimate for the whole task. Gary Boyle of Bering McKinley says you don't need to list every step and every next move. Josh Peterson adds that writing out the steps once can help build an honest estimate before you collapse them into a few weekly tasks.
What is the difference between an action item and a step?
An action item is a weekly task that moves a monthly goal forward, such as running a report and fixing what is broken. A step is one of the smaller moves inside that task. Gary Boyle calls the choice between the two the inflection point, and it depends on how well the person already knows the work.
Does giving employees detailed action items feel like micromanagement?
It can. On the episode, Josh Peterson shared feedback from a client leader who said a list of about 30 action items made them feel untrusted. Detailed steps help someone new to the work, but once the person can estimate the task, keep the plan at a few weekly items so capable leaders can own the details.
How often should a leadership team review action items?
Weekly, as long as a true yearly plan sits behind the meetings. Josh Peterson suggests the weekly meeting covers only action items: what got done, what didn't, and where people need help. One weekly meeting becomes the monthly review of financials and initiative goals, and one becomes the quarterly review of the initiatives themselves.
Why do strategic plans drift during the year?
Teams keep adding new action items, tasks, and even initiatives to their meetings, and each one seems reasonable when it arrives. Over time those additions pull the team away from the goals it set in planning. Gary Boyle recommends staying focused on the action items in the plan and on what you decided in your planning session months earlier.
How long does it take to know if a strategic plan is working?
Plan on about a year. Gary Boyle says time horizons are usually too short, and a single month can't separate a working plan from a lucky one. Set clear targets, follow the plan even when it feels like going through the motions, and check back. Then ask whether you can tie the results to the actions your team took.
Episode Highlights
- A client leader says 30 action items for one goal feels like distrust.
- The four layers of a plan: yearly plan, quarterly initiatives, monthly goals, weekly action items.
- Why Josh loads the plate so the weekly meeting is never empty.
- Using a full step list to build an honest time estimate, then moving to the highlight reel.
- The inflection point between a weekly task and the steps inside it.
- Action items with no link to a larger goal.
- Prioritizing and time binding the work instead of overloading the plan.
- How new ideas added to meetings cause plans to drift.
- A C plus process that still produced A plus results.
- Why short time horizons hide whether a plan is working.
About the Co-Host: Gary Boyle
Gary Boyle is COO and Management Consultant at Bering McKinley. He ran his own MSP before joining BMK and works with MSP leadership teams on operations, planning, and execution.
About the Host: Josh Peterson
Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.
Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →
Related Resources from Bering McKinley
- From planning to execution: translating business goals into performance targets
- Setting long-term goals in performance management
- The role of company performance analysis in strategic planning and long-term growth
Want to Continue the Conversation?
Right-sized action items only work when they trace back to a real yearly plan your team follows week after week. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.
%20logo.png?width=2000&height=369&name=BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png)