When to Switch from ConnectWise: Exploring the Competitive Landscape for MSP Professional Service Automation Tools in 2025

The Managed Service Provider (MSP) industry is rapidly evolving in 2025. With growing client expectations, increasing competition, and technological advancements, MSPs must constantly reassess the tools that drive their businesses. One critical aspect of operational efficiency for MSPs is Professional Services Automation (PSA) software. While ConnectWise has been a popular choice for years, many MSPs are beginning to explore alternatives. 

If you're an MSP owner or IT professional wondering whether it’s time to consider switching from ConnectWise, this blog will guide you through the key factors driving change, showcase promising competitors, and provide actionable advice for selecting the right PSA platform. 

Why Consider Switching from ConnectWise? 

ConnectWise has long been a staple for MSPs managing their operations, but even leading tools aren’t immune to limitations. Here are a few reasons MSPs might look for alternatives in 2025:

•  Complexity Over Simplicity: One of the common complaints about ConnectWise is its steep learning curve. Many small to mid-sized MSPs find it overly complex for their needs. 
• Customer Support Challenges: Over the years, some users have shared frustrations regarding slow response times and unfocused customer service. 
• Rising Costs: The pricing structure of ConnectWise doesn’t always scale well for smaller MSPs, making it less cost-effective in the long term. 
• Lack of Customization: Some MSPs find ConnectWise lacking the flexibility needed to align with their specific business workflows. 

If these pain points resonate with your team, it might be time to evaluate other options in the PSA market. 

Key Factors Driving the Need for Change 

As the MSP market becomes more competitive, companies are looking at PSA tools with fresh expectations. The following factors are driving this shift for many MSPs:

   A PSA tool should streamline operations—not complicate them. Platforms designed with intuitive user interfaces and simplified workflows are gaining popularity. 

   With tightened budgets, MSPs need tools that provide robust features without breaking the bank. Cost transparency and scalability are critical considerations. 

   Modern MSPs need PSA platforms that integrate seamlessly with Remote Monitoring and Management (RMM) tools, ticketing systems, and other core software. Advanced automation capabilities can save significant time and effort. 

   Excellent technical support is non-negotiable for businesses relying on PSA tools for mission-critical tasks. 

   MSPs must remain future-ready. PSA tools that invest in AI, analytics, and sophisticated reporting features lead the pack. 

Alternative PSA Tools for MSPs in 2025 

Thankfully, the PSA market is jam-packed with compelling options. Here are three promising alternatives to ConnectWise that are built with MSPs in mind. 

1. Atera 

Atera offers an all-in-one solution combining PSA and RMM functionalities in a single platform. 

Key Features:

• Fixed, predictable pricing. 
• Built-in remote access and monitoring tools. 
• Intuitive, user-friendly interface ideal for smaller MSPs. 

Why MSPs Love It:

It simplifies daily operations and is perfect for MSPs seeking a streamlined approach at an affordable price point. 

2. NinjaOne 

NinjaOne is an advanced RMM and PSA hybrid popular for its simple yet powerful features. 

Key Features:

• Lightning-fast integrations with third-party tools. 
• Customizable dashboards for real-time tracking. 
• Stellar customer support team. 

Why MSPs Love It:

NinjaOne puts a strong emphasis on automation and efficiency, helping MSPs run leaner and more competitive businesses. 

3. HaloPSA 

HaloPSA is another rising star for MSPs, providing a flexible and cost-effective solution bolstered by strong integrations. 

Key Features:

• Modular pricing plans that scale with your business. 
• Customizable workflows for greater adaptability. 
• Advanced analytics and reporting tools. 

Why MSPs Love It:

It offers MSPs the ability to finely tune the software to their specific needs without the development overhead. 

Features to Look for in a Modern PSA Tool 

When exploring connectwise competitors or evaluating PSA tools, prioritize these essential features to future-proof your operations: 

1. Customizable Dashboards for visibility over your business operations. 
2. Integrated RMM Solutions to ensure seamless workflows between ticketing, automation, and asset management. 
3. Automation Capabilities for efficient task management. 
4. Analytics and Insights for data-driven decision-making. 
5. Scalability to grow alongside your MSP business. 
6. Exceptional Support to ensure you’re never stuck during a mission-critical moment. 

By selecting a tool built with your team’s specific needs in mind, you’ll gain a competitive edge in the MSP industry. 

Making the Right Choice for Your MSP 

Choosing to switch PSA platforms isn’t a decision to take lightly, but it’s essential for staying competitive. Start by auditing how your current PSA tool is serving your business. Then, create a wishlist of features based on your pain points and desired outcomes. 

It’s equally critical to involve your entire team in the selection process to ensure the new tool aligns seamlessly with everyone’s workflow. Finally, take advantage of free trials and demos. Testing the waters before committing will help you feel confident in your decision. 

Bering McKinley's Role in MSP Optimization 

Feeling overwhelmed by all the options? That’s where Bering McKinley comes in. With two decades of experience, we specialize in helping MSPs optimize their systems, processes, and workflows. We’ve worked hands-on with platforms like ConnectWise, Atera, HaloPSA, and more. Our team offers custom guidance, whether you’re weighing new options, configuring a new PSA platform, or fine-tuning your existing tools. 

We’ve helped hundreds of MSPs achieve measurable growth. Now it’s your turn. Reach out to Bering McKinley today to take your MSP operations to the next level. 

Future-Proof Your PSA Strategy 

The right PSA tool can revolutionize your MSP's efficiency, profitability, and customer satisfaction. And while ConnectWise has set a strong precedent, it’s worth exploring alternatives that may better suit your specific needs in 2025. 

Whether you're looking to streamline operations with NinjaOne, simplify workflows with Atera, or tailor solutions with HaloPSA, the key is finding a partner who understands your challenges and equips you with the tools for success. 

Are you ready to explore your options? Contact Bering McKinley for expert consulting to identify, configure, and implement the ideal PSA solution for your MSP business.