How Do MSPs Measure Agreement Profit?
MSPs measure agreement profit with two numbers: agreement gross profit (AGP), which is agreement revenue minus licensing and labor cost, and effective hourly rate (EHR), which is agreement revenue minus licensing divided by the hours your team puts in. On this episode, Josh Peterson puts the AGP target for a standard managed services contract at 65%, which matches Bering McKinley's standard of 65% of agreement revenue. For more background, read why agreement gross profit deserves more of your attention and how to set up ConnectWise agreements that hold up over time.
Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, talks with Ryan Alter, a former MSP owner, about why many MSPs keep clients running and secure but struggle with the economics of managed services, and how AGP, EHR, and service salaries fit together.
How Do MSPs Measure Agreement Profit?
Start with agreement gross profit: agreement revenue minus the licensing cost included in the agreement minus the labor cost of the hours your team put against it. Josh walks through the math on the episode with deliberately simple numbers. A $1,000 monthly agreement carries $100 of licensing, and technicians who cost $20 an hour put in five hours, or $100 of labor. That leaves $800, an 80% agreement gross profit. The formula is easy; trusting the inputs is the hard part.
Every tool included in the agreement, such as antivirus or firewall licensing, has to be set up as an agreement addition so its cost is tracked. Member costs have to be loaded, agreement types have to be separated so block time is not mixed with managed services, and time entry has to be accurate. Josh notes that the ConnectWise agreement gross profit report is a good report when the PSA is set up well. When a report looks wrong, that is where the work starts, not where the conversation ends.
- AGP is agreement revenue minus licensing cost minus labor cost, divided by agreement revenue.
- Set up every included license as an agreement addition so its cost lands on the agreement.
- Fix member costs, agreement types, and time entry before you trust any AGP report.
What Agreement Gross Profit Should an MSP Target?
For a standard managed services contract, Josh's target on the episode is 65%, and Bering McKinley's standard is the same: 65% of agreement revenue. He is happy for an MSP at 63% and thrilled for one at 70%, but he warns that very high AGP can come from underserving clients, and that shows up in client satisfaction. The bigger gap he sees is pricing without a margin in mind.
Owners set rates by what competitors charge and what the market will bear, and rarely ask how to price an agreement so it reaches a target gross profit for the hours they expect to spend. Josh calls labor the biggest driver of AGP, with licensing second. Ryan adds that licensing creeps: new tools get added to packages as extra value for the client, and nobody goes back to adjust the price. When AGP is low, Josh says the cause is rarely just undercharging or a difficult client. It is often both pricing and how the service is delivered.
- Price each agreement for a target gross profit, not only for what the market will bear.
- Revisit agreement pricing whenever you add a tool or license to a package.
- Treat low AGP as a pricing question and a delivery question at the same time.
How Do You Calculate Effective Hourly Rate on Managed Services?
Effective hourly rate tells you how much an agreement actually pays per hour of work. Josh's definition starts with what he calls spendable revenue: agreement revenue minus licensing costs, without subtracting labor. A $1,000 agreement with $100 of licensing leaves $900 you can spend however you choose, on your own technicians, on an outsourced provider, or on nothing at all. Divide that spendable revenue by the hours put against the agreement and you have its EHR.
Josh says no PSA button produces an accurate number, so expect to do the math by hand from your agreement gross profit report. The benchmark he uses is your standard hourly rate. A quick portfolio test from the episode is to total all agreement hours in a month, multiply by your standard rate, and compare the result with your agreement revenue. Ryan, who ran a largely hourly shop, says his rate was about $150 an hour while his effective rate ran around $130, and well-bid flat-rate projects made up the difference.
- EHR is agreement revenue minus licensing, divided by the hours worked on the agreement.
- Compare agreement EHR with your standard hourly rate every month.
- If agreements fall short, know where else in the business you make up the gap.
Why Don't AGP and EHR Always Move Together?
AGP and EHR measure different things, so one can look healthy while the other does not. AGP considers labor cost, hours, and revenue; EHR considers only revenue and hours. Josh says it seems intuitive that high AGP means high EHR, but you can have either combination, and the mismatch tells you where to look. High EHR with low AGP suggests expensive technicians are doing the work: few hours, but costly ones. That makes dispatch a profit decision, not only a service decision.
Josh's example is choosing between a senior technician who costs $90 an hour and a junior technician who costs $35 an hour and will do a good enough job. On a $1,000 agreement with $900 of spendable revenue and a $150 rack rate, he budgets six hours, which leaves room to send a less expensive technician who takes longer. His sequence is to know the formula, study what you have, and form hypotheses about why an agreement is off before blaming the client.
- Read AGP and EHR side by side; a mismatch points to the cause.
- High EHR with low AGP often means costly technicians on routine work.
- Teach dispatchers what AGP and EHR mean so the right person gets sent.
What Should Service Salaries Be as a Percentage of Service Revenue?
Josh's answer is 33%, and Bering McKinley's standard is the same: service salaries at 33% of service revenue. Service payroll includes technicians, dispatchers, service managers, and project managers, counting only W2 wages and required payroll taxes; benefits go to G&A. Service revenue has three types, recurring, project, and hourly, kept apart from the two other revenue buckets, product and resold cloud. Josh is strict about the number.
On $100,000 of monthly service revenue, one point over costs $1,000 a month, and it rarely stays at one point. Ryan, who calls it one of the most staffing-relevant numbers he managed, read 30% as a sign his team was running too hard and 35% to 37% as a sign he was overstaffed. Josh frames the service manager's job as keeping these service numbers in balance with utilization, client satisfaction, and employee satisfaction, and he expects anyone with the manager title to know them well.
- Count W2 wages and payroll taxes for every service role; put benefits in G&A.
- Treat sustained drift above 33% as an alarm, not a rounding error.
- A ratio well below target can mean your team is running too hard.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do MSPs measure agreement profit?
Most MSPs measure agreement profit with two numbers: agreement gross profit and effective hourly rate. AGP subtracts licensing and labor cost from agreement revenue. EHR subtracts licensing only and divides by the hours worked. Read together every month, the two numbers show whether an agreement is priced well, delivered efficiently, and staffed with the right technicians.
What is agreement gross profit for an MSP?
Agreement gross profit is the share of agreement revenue left after you subtract the licensing included in the agreement and the cost of the labor spent on it. In Josh Peterson's example, a $1,000 agreement with $100 of licensing and $100 of labor delivers $800, which is an 80% agreement gross profit.
What is a good agreement gross profit percentage for managed services?
Bering McKinley's standard for agreement gross profit is 65% of agreement revenue, and Josh uses the same 65% target for a standard managed services contract on the episode. Measure block-time agreements separately from managed services agreements, and remember that AGP far above target can mean clients are being underserved.
How do you calculate effective hourly rate for an MSP agreement?
Subtract licensing costs from the agreement revenue to get spendable revenue, then divide by the hours your team put against the agreement that month. Labor cost is not subtracted. Compare the result with your standard hourly rate. Most PSA tools will not calculate it for you, so expect to work it out from your agreement report.
What counts as service revenue for an MSP?
Service revenue has three types: recurring agreement revenue, project revenue, and hourly revenue. Product sales and resold cloud are separate revenue buckets with their own margins. Keeping the three service types together, and apart from product and resold cloud, is what makes service department gross profit and the service salaries ratio meaningful.
Why is my MSP not profitable with strong recurring revenue?
Recurring revenue does not guarantee profit. Underpriced agreements, licenses added without a price change, and expensive technicians on routine work all leak margin. Josh says more revenue will not fix it, because new revenue delivers the same margin as today's. Check your numbers against Bering McKinley's standards of 55% service department gross profit on service revenue and 17% net profit on total revenue.
Episode Highlights
- Why knowing your numbers matters as much as keeping clients up and secure
- The agreement gross profit formula, worked through with simple numbers
- What has to be set up in your PSA before an AGP report can be trusted
- Why labor cost is the biggest driver of agreement gross profit
- How license creep erodes agreement margins
- Defining effective hourly rate with spendable revenue
- Why AGP and EHR do not always move together
- Dispatch as a profit decision, not only a service decision
- The service salaries to service revenue ratio and what it includes
- The three types of service revenue and the other two revenue buckets
About the Guest: Ryan Alter
Ryan Alter is a former MSP owner from Missoula, Montana. Over about 20 years, he grew his company from a one-person shop to a 25-person team before selling it. His business did more hourly work than recurring work, which gives him a practical view of where managed services margins come from and how projects can make up the difference.
Connect with Ryan on LinkedIn →
About the Host: Josh Peterson
Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.
Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →
Related Resources from Bering McKinley
- The magic number when calculating your gross profit margin
- Why your MSP needs a dispatcher
- What your financials are telling you about your business
Want to Continue the Conversation?
AGP, EHR, and service salaries only improve when someone reviews them every month and acts on what they show. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.
%20logo.png?width=1083&height=200&name=BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png)