Bering McKinley Blog

Consultants Over Technicians: The Premier MSP

Written by Gary Boyle | Apr 1, 2026 11:00:00 AM

The MSP industry has spent two decades perfecting a pitch that sounds different but delivers the same thing. Every owner says they're not like other MSPs, but strip away the branding and most are competing on the same terrain: uptime, ticket speed, and security posture. Those things matter — they're critical, in fact — but they've become the floor, not the ceiling. The real question facing MSP owners today isn't whether they can keep the lights on. It's whether they can define a direction beyond revenue and build a practice that delivers strategic business value their clients can't find anywhere else. That shift doesn't start with a new tool or a new service line. It starts with who you hire and what you empower them to do. For owners navigating this transition, understanding why hourly and project billing still matters is essential to building a revenue model that rewards the value you actually deliver.

Bryon Beilman has been running iuvo Technologies out of Boston for 19 years, and his answer to the commoditization problem is deceptively simple: hire people who are smarter than you, call them consultants instead of technicians, and build a culture where they're empowered to ask the questions that matter. His team averages 24 years of experience. When a prospect asks how they handle password resets, the genuine answer is that they don't have that problem. That's not a marketing line — it's the natural outcome of a deliberate decision to compete on judgment, not volume. The implications ripple through every part of the business: pricing moves to retainers instead of per-device contracts, the ideal client profile narrows to companies that value strategic partnership, and AI becomes a growth lever for business conversations rather than another tool on the stack. The result is an MSP that charges for what it knows, not just what it fixes.

Listen on Your Favorite Platform

The Consultant Hiring Decision That Changes Everything

There's a structural problem embedded in the way most MSPs build their teams. The default is to hire technicians — people who are good at fixing things, closing tickets, and moving on to the next problem. It works. It scales in a predictable way. But it creates a ceiling that most owners don't see until they're already pressed against it. When your team is built around resolving problems, your clients will only ever see you as the people who resolve problems. They won't ask you for strategic guidance because nothing in the relationship signals that you have it to offer. The decision to hire consultants — people with deep experience, business acumen, and the ability to ask uncomfortable questions — is not a staffing preference. It's a positioning decision that reshapes every client interaction from the first meeting forward.

  • When you staff for ticket resolution, you train your clients to value you on speed and uptime. When you staff for judgment, you train them to value you on insight.
  • A team averaging 24 years of experience doesn't need a better ticketing system. They need the latitude to have the conversations that prevent tickets from being created in the first place.
  • The word "consultant" isn't just semantics. It sets an expectation — for the employee, the client, and the market — about the kind of value that walks through the door.

Revenue Model Evolution: From Per-Device to Retainer to Project

The managed services pricing model that dominated the last two decades was built on a specific promise: predictable costs for the client, predictable revenue for the MSP. That promise still holds value, but the model has been driven toward the bottom by competition and vendor pressure. Per-device and per-user pricing rewards volume, not value. It makes it structurally difficult to charge for the kinds of strategic conversations that actually differentiate a premier MSP. The shift to retainer-based contracts — where the scope is defined by outcomes and access rather than device counts — creates room to deliver high-value work without the constant friction of justifying every hour. And when you pair retainers with deliberate project-based revenue for both existing and net-new clients, you build a revenue engine that rewards expertise instead of punishing it.

  • Retainers decouple revenue from device counts and create space for strategic work that doesn't fit neatly into a ticket queue.
  • Project revenue — especially for non-recurring clients — serves as a proving ground. It's the chance to demonstrate value before a long-term commitment is on the table.
  • The MSPs that resist project and hourly work because vendors told them it was dead are leaving real revenue and real client relationships on the table.

The Discipline of Saying No: ICP Narrowing as a Growth Strategy

One of the most counterintuitive moves an MSP owner can make is to fire clients. Not the ones who don't pay — that's obvious. The ones who pay on time but consume disproportionate energy because they don't value what you actually do. The manufacturing client who wants to see how long they can keep a Windows 98 machine running. The break-fix holdout who resists every attempt at a recurring relationship. These clients aren't just low-margin — they actively prevent you from becoming the company you need to be. Narrowing the ideal client profile is not about arrogance or selectivity for its own sake. It's about creating the conditions where your best people can do their best work for clients who recognize and reward that work.

  • The clients you lose when you raise standards are almost always the ones who were costing you the most in hidden ways — late payments, scope creep, cultural misalignment, and team burnout.
  • Cultural alignment between MSP and client is not a nice-to-have. It's a prerequisite for the kind of strategic partnership that produces real business outcomes.
  • Every hour your best consultant spends band-aiding a client who doesn't fit is an hour they're not spending on the client who would pay three times as much for genuine strategic value.

AI as a Business Conversation, Not a Technology Play

The most dangerous thing an MSP can do right now is treat AI as a punchline or a passing trend. The second most dangerous thing is to treat it as just another tool on the stack. AI is neither. It's a fundamental shift in how business problems get solved, and the MSPs that figure out how to lead that conversation with their clients — not just implement the technology — will define the next decade of the industry. The opportunity isn't in selling AI services. It's in being the company that helps a client understand why their two-week quoting cycle is a growth bottleneck, and then using AI to compress it to a single day. The technology is the enabler. The business conversation is the value.

  • Clients are already experimenting with AI on their own — vibe coding prototypes, building internal tools, automating reports. The wild west is happening with or without the MSP's involvement.
  • The MSP's opportunity is not to prevent the experimentation but to be ready when the prototypes start breaking. Structure, governance, and scalability are where the real consulting value lives.
  • If you're waiting for a vendor to package AI into a recurring revenue product before you engage with it, you've already ceded the strategic conversation to someone else.

Charging for What You Know: The Billing Confidence Gap

There is a moment in the growth of every MSP where the owner realizes they're adding value that goes far beyond the managed services agreement — and they're not charging for it. The strategic meeting. The business process conversation. The AI roadmap discussion. These are the interactions that clients value most, and they're the ones MSP owners are most reluctant to bill for. Part of it is scar tissue from years of low agreement gross profit and scope creep. Part of it is the psychological difficulty of saying "I charge this" when you've spent your career saying "my company charges this." But left unchecked, that gap between value delivered and value captured doesn't just cost revenue. It trains the market to expect strategic consulting for free from every MSP that walks through the door.

  • The transition from commodity pricing to value-based billing will be messy. Mistakes are inevitable — underbilling some clients, overbilling others, struggling to define where the meter starts. That's the cost of evolution, and it's worth paying.
  • If you can't articulate why a four-hour strategic meeting is worth billing for, the problem isn't the client's perception of value. It's yours.
  • The MSP owners who get comfortable charging for judgment — not just labor — will separate themselves permanently from the ones still competing on ticket speed and device counts.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does it mean to hire consultants instead of technicians in an MSP?

Hiring consultants means prioritizing business acumen, client communication skills, and deep experience alongside technical ability. Technicians are hired to resolve problems. Consultants are hired to understand why problems exist, prevent them from recurring, and have strategic conversations with clients about their business — not just their technology. The distinction shapes how clients perceive and value the MSP relationship.

How does a retainer model differ from traditional per-device MSP pricing?

Per-device pricing ties revenue to hardware counts and incentivizes volume over value. A retainer model defines scope around outcomes, access, and strategic services — creating room for high-value work like business process consulting, AI enablement, and compliance guidance that doesn't map neatly to a per-device or per-user metric. Retainers reward the depth of the relationship rather than the breadth of the infrastructure.

Should MSPs pursue project revenue from non-recurring clients?

Yes. Projects for non-recurring clients serve as a proving ground — a chance to demonstrate the quality of your team and the depth of your expertise before a long-term commitment is on the table. When a project is delivered well, it naturally leads to follow-on conversations and deeper engagement. MSPs that refuse project work outside their recurring base are limiting their growth surface and missing their best opportunity to win new relationships.

How should MSPs approach AI as a service offering?

Start with the business problem, not the technology. AI is most valuable when it eliminates a specific bottleneck — compressing a two-week quoting cycle into one day, automating a report that took hours to compile, or surfacing insights from data a client didn't know they had. MSPs that lead with business conversations and use AI as the solution — rather than leading with AI as the product — will build more durable client relationships and command higher fees.

What is an ideal client profile (ICP) and why should MSPs narrow theirs?

An ideal client profile defines the type of company that gets the most value from your services and delivers the best outcomes for your business — in revenue, profitability, cultural alignment, and team satisfaction. Narrowing the ICP means deliberately choosing not to serve clients who don't fit, even if they pay on time. The result is higher margins, less scope creep, stronger retention, and a team that can focus on delivering their best work instead of managing misaligned expectations.

How do MSPs get comfortable charging for strategic business value?

It starts with recognizing that the knowledge and judgment you bring to a client conversation has real, measurable value — separate from the technology you implement. Many MSP owners find it easier to say "my company charges this" before they can say "I charge this." That's a normal transition. The key is to start billing for strategic work now, accept that the pricing won't be perfect immediately, and iterate. Every strategic meeting you give away for free trains the market to expect it for free from everyone.

Episode Highlights

  • 00:21 — Why leaving the startup world for IT services felt like building on a foundation you actually control
  • 03:25 — The accelerating rate at which traditional MSP services are becoming table stakes for sophisticated clients
  • 04:49 — What separates the MSP that says "we're different" from the one that actually is
  • 06:16 — The cultural decision to hire consultants with an average of 24 years experience — and what it does to client conversations
  • 08:04 — "How do you handle password resets?" — the question that reveals whether you're competing on problems or outcomes
  • 11:52 — Asking "why" five levels deep to find the real business problem hiding behind the technology request
  • 13:31 — Why curiosity is the single most important trait to screen for in a sales hire
  • 17:09 — The evolution from break-fix to managed services to retainer-based consulting and what each transition cost
  • 18:12 — Narrowing the ICP: the clients you lose are almost always the ones you should have fired years ago
  • 20:18 — Using AI to compress a two-week quoting process into a single day — and what that means for deal velocity
  • 22:28 — The case for project and hourly revenue alongside recurring — and why the vendor narrative against it is self-serving
  • 24:05 — Death by a thousand paper cuts: the vendor conference tool trap and how to escape it
  • 33:23 — What the MSP consultant of the future looks like — and why it starts with business analysis, not technical certifications
  • 36:12 — Vibe coding, decentralized AI experimentation, and why the chaos is the MSP's biggest opportunity
  • 44:14 — The billing tension: should you charge for a strategic meeting with an existing client?
  • 48:18 — "My company charges this" — the psychological shift that unlocks value-based pricing
  • 49:40 — Bryon's book Leadership at the Edge and the blueprint for building an empowering culture

About the Guest: Bryon Beilman

Bryon Beilman is President and CEO of iuvo Technologies, a Boston-based IT consulting and managed services firm he co-founded in 2007. With more than 30 years in IT and systems management spanning startups, enterprise, and government, Bryon has built iuvo into a premier provider known for hiring experienced consultants and delivering strategic business value to sophisticated clients across New England and beyond. He is the author of Leadership at the Edge: Embracing the Hyperloop Mindset to Accelerate Business Growth and Success and co-hosts the Edge of Excellence podcast on leadership, culture, and technology.

Connect with Bryon on LinkedIn →

About the Host: Josh Peterson

Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.

Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →

Related Resources from Bering McKinley

Want to Continue the Conversation?

Building a premier MSP means making deliberate decisions about who you hire, who you serve, and what you charge for. The BMK Vision Operating System helps MSP owners turn those decisions into a structured path toward operational maturity and long-term profitability.