---
title: Is Building Your Own MSP Software Worth It?
description: Is building your own MSP software worth it? Josh Peterson and Gary Boyle run the math on tool spend, rising PSA prices, and when building your own tools pays.
image: https://beringmckinley.com/hubfs/%23120%20-%20MSP%20Software%20Costs%20When%20Building%20Your%20Own%20Actually%20Pays%20%20BMK%20VISION%20ROUNDTABLE.png
---

[Skip to content](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/should-an-msp-build-its-own-software-instead-of-paying-for-it#main-content)

[![Bering McKinley Logo](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png?width=2000&height=369&name=BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png "Bering McKinley Logo")](https://beringmckinley.com)

- [What We Do](https://beringmckinley.com/vision) 
    - [BMK Vision](https://beringmckinley.com/vision)
    - [MSP Benchmark](https://beringmckinley.com/msp-benchmark)
    - [Inside the Vision App](https://beringmckinley.com/vision-app)
- [About](https://beringmckinley.com/about) 
    - [Team](https://beringmckinley.com/team)
    - [Consult with BMK](https://beringmckinley.com/consult-with-bmk)
- [Blog](https://beringmckinley.com/blog)
- [Podcast](https://beringmckinley.com/bmkvisionpodcast)
- [The Vision Brief](https://beringmckinley.com/the-vision-brief)
- [Contact](https://beringmckinley.com/contact)
- [Text us](SMS:212.300.3016)
- [Vision | Log in](https://app.bmkvision.com)

Search

- There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

# Is Building Your Own MSP Software Worth It?

Aug 31, 2026 · BMK Vision Roundtable

For most MSPs, building your own software just to cut the tool bill doesn't pay yet. In Gary Boyle's example, an MSP paying about $3,000 a month for its tool stack has roughly $40,000 a year at most to save, which covers about half a year of an $80,000 level two technician, and that isn't enough to build a real replacement. Building is far cheaper than it used to be, but it makes the most sense for larger MSPs with big tool bills or for a group of peer MSPs that share the work. Before you price a build, look at how your own pricing works, starting with [why leaning only on recurring revenue can hide inefficiency](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/dont-get-hooked-on-recurring-revenue) and [what agreement gross profit tells you about each contract](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/why-youre-not-paying-enough-attention-to-agreement-gross-profits).

In this BMK Vision Roundtable, Josh Peterson, CEO of Bering McKinley, and Gary Boyle, COO and Management Consultant, talk through why software prices keep rising, how a consumption model could realign incentives, and when an MSP should build its own tools.

<iframe class="hs-responsive-embed-iframe" style="position: absolute; top: 0; left: 0; width: 100%; height: 100%; border: none;" title="Is Building Your Own MSP Software Worth It? Josh Peterson and Gary Boyle on the BMK Vision Podcast" xml="lang" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/TpMpDHIiH_0" width="560" height="315" allowfullscreen loading="lazy" data-service="youtube"></iframe>

## Is Building Your Own MSP Software Worth It?

It is worth it when the bill you would replace is big enough to fund the build, and for most MSPs it isn't. Gary points out that an MSP with a very large monthly tool bill has a real budget to work against, and over five years that money adds up to a serious case for building in-house. A smaller MSP is in a different spot. If its stack costs about $3,000 a month, the most it can save is roughly $40,000 a year, and Gary doesn't think anyone builds something of substance for that, least of all a level two technician working on it for half a year. As he put it, "it's still expensive to build. It's just way less expensive to build than it used to be." He also cautions that a home-built tool may not be a like-for-like replacement, so the savings case needs to be honest about what the new tool would actually do.

- Size the build against the money you would actually stop spending.
- Count your own team's hours as a real cost of building.
- Expect larger MSPs to have the clearest case for building in-house.

## Why Do PSA and RMM Prices Keep Going Up?

Prices climb because of how the software was bundled and because input costs keep rising. Gary explains that software used to be bought like minutes on a cell phone: you paid for what you used, which made cost easy to understand. When vendors moved to a low flat monthly fee, many customers signed up and barely used the product because it was cheap enough to ignore. Growth inside that base never came, so a few years in, the remaining lever was raising prices every year and making contracts harder to leave. On top of that, labor is the biggest input for a software company, and it rises with the cost of living whether anyone likes it or not. Gary's point is that a company holding its price while costs rise is simply choosing to make less money. Josh has heard many owners describe the other side of this, with tool costs growing year after year and cancellations that are hard to get through.

- Separate cost increases you can't argue with from pure margin increases.
- Read longer, harder-to-exit contracts as part of the same pricing pattern.
- Remember that the same input costs push on your own rates.

## Do MSPs Use Most of What Their Tools Can Do?

Very few do, which is why a simpler, cheaper tool can be good enough. Gary describes three levels of tool maturity from his years running an MSP. At level one, the PSA and RMM are a big help and you can't imagine running without them. At level two, you build some workflows and scripts and get real work done, but you hit a wall where setup gets confusing and it's hard to measure the gain. Level three is full automation where you take on more customers without hiring, and Gary says it's very rare for anyone to get there. Meanwhile, the integrations that made big platforms attractive matter less, because most tools have an API and an MSP can now build its own connection. "We love options. We never use them, but we love them," Gary said. A good enough tool tracks tickets, handles invoicing, organizes clients, sends email, and adds remote management.

- List the features your team actually uses before comparing tools.
- Expect gains past basic automation to take dedicated effort or people.
- Check for an API before paying extra for a built-in integration.

## Should an MSP Move to a Consumption Pricing Model?

It's worth considering, because a consumption model lines up what the client pays with what they get. Josh's favorite way to offer IT services is a base fee that covers the tools needed to monitor and secure the environment, plus payment for the support time the client actually uses. He argues the flat fee swung too far from hourly billing: hourly was said to pay you when the client is in pain, but a flat fee says, in Josh's words, "pay me a fixed fee and I hope you never call." He sees help desks that are still reactive, with the phone ringing about problems the MSP didn't catch first. Gary doesn't think the flat-rate model is broken, since tracking agreement profitability answers much of it, but he agrees incentives drift. The catch Josh hears from owners is valuation, because buyers of MSPs place a high value on recurring revenue.

- Ask whether a client who saw no work last month would accept your bill.
- Price the tools that protect the client separately from support time.
- Weigh better alignment against how buyers value recurring revenue.

## Should You Build Software for Your MSP or for the Market?

Build it for your own MSP first, and treat selling it as a separate business. Josh's advice to an owner with development curiosity is simple: "Build it for yourself, right? Just save your own money." If other MSPs show interest, let it grow from there. Going to market is a different thesis, because the product matters less than whether you can market it, build a community, and support it. Gary adds that one MSP leaving a large vendor for its own tool sends no signal, since it's a single customer. What would get attention is 50, 100, or 200 MSPs moving to a cheaper shared system together. For smaller MSPs that can't justify a solo build, he suggests getting together with peers who are already building with AI, proving a concept internally, and bringing in a development team to finish it if it holds up. Large vendors can copy the technology, but matching a lean cost structure is much harder.

- Decide up front whether you are cutting a cost or starting a product company.
- Look for other MSPs already building before starting alone.
- Plan for sales and support before taking a tool to market.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Is it worth it for an MSP to build its own software?

Only when the tool spend it replaces is large enough to pay for the build. In Gary Boyle's example, an MSP paying about $3,000 a month has roughly $40,000 a year at most to save, which isn't enough to build a real PSA or RMM replacement. MSPs with much larger tool bills have a far stronger case.

### How much tool spend does an MSP need before building pays off?

There is no fixed line, but the savings have to cover real development time. Gary's comparison is that $40,000 a year buys about half a year of an $80,000 level two technician, which won't produce a substitute for a full stack. Building is much cheaper than it used to be, yet for a small MSP it can still cost more than it saves.

### Why do PSA and RMM prices increase every year?

Gary Boyle points to two causes. Low flat monthly fees created a base of customers who barely used the product, so vendors turned to yearly price increases and longer contracts when growth stalled. Labor costs also keep rising with the cost of living, and a vendor that doesn't raise prices is choosing to make less money.

### What is a consumption pricing model for managed services?

As Josh Peterson describes it, the client pays a base fee for the tools that monitor and secure their environment, then pays for the support time they actually use. He sees it as more balanced than a flat fee, which can reward doing as little as possible. The tradeoff is that buyers of MSPs tend to value recurring revenue highly.

### Can an MSP build its own tools with AI?

Yes. Gary Boyle says an owner who spends some time with AI coding tools will find they can build real software that solves real problems, even if it isn't perfect. Most platforms have an API, so an MSP can build its own integrations instead of paying for a platform mainly because other software already connects to it.

### Should an MSP sell the software it builds for itself?

Josh Peterson advises building for yourself first and letting other MSPs adopt it naturally if they ask. Taking a tool to market is a different business that depends on marketing, community, and support more than on the product. Gary Boyle adds that groups of MSPs moving together send a stronger signal to large vendors than one MSP leaving.

---

## Listen on Your Favorite Platform

- [![Apple Podcasts](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/apple-podcast-Dec-10-2025-07-28-27-9346-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=apple-podcast-Dec-10-2025-07-28-27-9346-PM.png)](https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-bmk-vision-podcast/id1827082235)
- [![YouTube](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/youtube_logo-Dec-10-2025-07-28-29-0952-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=youtube_logo-Dec-10-2025-07-28-29-0952-PM.png)](https://www.youtube.com/@beringmckinleyvision?sub_confirmation=1)
- [![YouTube Music](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/youtube-music-logo-Dec-10-2025-07-28-35-3603-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=youtube-music-logo-Dec-10-2025-07-28-35-3603-PM.png)](https://music.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL03jvZSuXCDFHzZFwDdTs1xP07b8AI_5P)
- [![Spotify](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/spotify-Dec-10-2025-07-28-26-8422-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=spotify-Dec-10-2025-07-28-26-8422-PM.png)](https://open.spotify.com/show/6iYx2sDBy2YnN3V2YA9GyW)
- [![Amazon Music](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/AmazonMusic-Dec-10-2025-07-28-23-6763-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=AmazonMusic-Dec-10-2025-07-28-23-6763-PM.png)](https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/33fb1a31-0a2b-4478-80b9-38fc3c552675/the-bmk-vision-podcast)
- [![Podbean](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/podbean-app-Dec-10-2025-07-28-34-3341-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=podbean-app-Dec-10-2025-07-28-34-3341-PM.png)](https://www.podbean.com/pw/pbblog-k23bf-14140db?from=usersite)
- [![iHeartRadio](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/iHeartRadio-Dec-10-2025-07-28-30-0468-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=iHeartRadio-Dec-10-2025-07-28-30-0468-PM.png)](https://www.iheart.com/podcast/1333-the-bmk-vision-podcast-289236584/)
- [![Player FM](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/PlayerFM-Dec-10-2025-07-28-36-3797-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=PlayerFM-Dec-10-2025-07-28-36-3797-PM.png)](https://player.fm/series/the-bmk-vision-podcast)
- [![Listen Notes](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/listener-Dec-10-2025-07-28-24-7354-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=listener-Dec-10-2025-07-28-24-7354-PM.png)](https://www.listennotes.com/podcasts/the-bmk-vision-podcast-josh-peterson-7iS7AIHHUhL/)
- [![Podchaser](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/Podchaser-Dec-10-2025-07-28-31-1542-PM.webp?width=40&height=40&name=Podchaser-Dec-10-2025-07-28-31-1542-PM.webp)](https://www.podchaser.com/podcasts/the-bmk-vision-podcast-5871877)
- [![BoomPlay](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Imported_Blog_Media/BoomPlay-Dec-10-2025-07-28-25-8023-PM.png?width=40&height=40&name=BoomPlay-Dec-10-2025-07-28-25-8023-PM.png)](https://www.boomplaymusic.com/podcasts/136263)

---

## Episode Highlights

- Why so many MSP owners describe the same vendor billing frustrations.
- How low bundled monthly fees led to yearly price increases.
- Rising labor costs and what holding a price really means.
- The case for a consumption model with a base fee plus time used.
- Three levels of PSA and RMM maturity, and why few reach the third.
- What a good enough PSA actually needs to do.
- Building integrations yourself when a tool has an API.
- Building a tool for yourself versus building it for the market.
- The math on when building your own tools pays.
- Why MSPs moving together send a stronger signal than one leaving.

## About the Co-Host: Gary Boyle

Gary Boyle is COO and Management Consultant at Bering McKinley. He ran his own MSP before joining BMK and works with MSP leadership teams on operations, planning, and execution.

## About the Host: Josh Peterson

Josh Peterson is the CEO of Bering McKinley and host of The BMK Vision Podcast. Since 2004, Josh has worked with hundreds of MSP owners to build operationally sound, profitable businesses through consulting, peer teams, and direct coaching.

[Connect with Josh Peterson on LinkedIn →](https://www.linkedin.com/in/joshdpeterson/)

## Related Resources from Bering McKinley

- [How artificial intelligence is transforming MSP software for IT support](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/how-artificial-intelligence-is-transforming-msp-software-for-it-support)
- [Why billing your clients hourly is worth your time](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/billing-your-clients-hourly-is-worth-your-time)
- [Future-proofing your MSP for the next wave of technological change](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/future-proofing-your-msp-preparing-for-the-next-wave-of-technological-change)

## Want to Continue the Conversation?

Whether you build, buy, or renegotiate your tools, the decision should rest on your own numbers. Vision gives your MSP a strategic plan, a consultant who holds your team accountable every month, and your numbers tracked against BMK's standards.

[Apply to be a Guest](https://beringmckinley.com/bmkvisionpodcast#be-a-guest) [Learn More About Vision](https://beringmckinley.com/vision)

[BMK Vision Roundtable](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/tag/bmk-vision-roundtable)

### Related Posts

<https://beringmckinley.com/blog/should-your-msp-build-its-own-integrations-instead-of-paying-for-middleware>

###### [Should an MSP Build Its Own Integrations?](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/should-your-msp-build-its-own-integrations-instead-of-paying-for-middleware)

An MSP should build its own integrations only where it can own the production risk, because AI has made building cheap but has not made running it...

<https://beringmckinley.com/blog/msps-are-being-commoditized-heres-the-way-out>

###### [How Can an MSP Avoid Becoming a Commodity?](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/msps-are-being-commoditized-heres-the-way-out)

An MSP avoids becoming a commodity by selling what can't be packaged and compared on price: business advisory, custom development, and eventually...

<https://beringmckinley.com/blog/should-your-msp-sell-the-app-you-built-with-claude>

###### [Should Your MSP Sell Apps Built With AI?](https://beringmckinley.com/blog/should-your-msp-sell-the-app-you-built-with-claude)

Yes, if you sell it as a proof of concept to a client who understands what that means, and you agree up front on who supports it and who owns the...

[![Bering McKinley Logo](https://beringmckinley.com/hs-fs/hubfs/BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png?width=2000&height=369&name=BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png "Bering McKinley Logo")](https://beringmckinley.com)

[What We Do](https://beringmckinley.com/vision)  
[MSP Benchmark](https://beringmckinley.com/msp-benchmark)  
[Inside the Vision App](https://beringmckinley.com/vision-app)  
[About](https://beringmckinley.com/about)  
[Team](https://beringmckinley.com/team)  
[Consult with BMK](https://beringmckinley.com/consult-with-bmk)  
[Blog](https://beringmckinley.com/blog)  
[Podcast](https://beringmckinley.com/bmkvisionpodcast)  
[The Vision Brief](https://beringmckinley.com/the-vision-brief)  
[Contact](https://beringmckinley.com/contact)  
[Vision | Log in](https://app.bmkvision.com)  
[Careers](https://beringmckinley.com/careers)

#### Bering McKinley

650 Warrenville Road  
Suite 100 #1007  
Lisle, IL 60532

Phone: 212.300.3016

[Text us: 212.300.3016](SMS:212.300.3016)  
Email: [info@beringmckinley.com](mailto:info@beringmckinley.com)  
[Book a walk-through](https://meetings.hubspot.com/joshpeterson/vision-walk-through)

[Policies, Terms and Conditions](https://beringmckinley.com/policy)

##### Follow Us

[Follow us on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/BeringMckinley) [Follow us on Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/beringmckinley/?hl=en) [Follow us on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/bering-mckinley) [Follow us on X](https://twitter.com/beringmckinley)

© 2026 All rights reserved. Bering McKinley

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Gary Boyle",
    "url" : "https://beringmckinley.com/blog/author/gary-boyle"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-19T21:26:10.930Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-08-31T12:00:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "Is Building Your Own MSP Software Worth It?",
  "image" : [ "https://beringmckinley.com/hubfs/%23120%20-%20MSP%20Software%20Costs%20When%20Building%20Your%20Own%20Actually%20Pays%20%20BMK%20VISION%20ROUNDTABLE.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://beringmckinley.com/blog/should-an-msp-build-its-own-software-instead-of-paying-for-it",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://beringmckinley.com/hubfs/BMK%20(just%20text)%20logo.png"
    },
    "name" : "Bering McKinley"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "VideoObject",
  "contentUrl" : "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TpMpDHIiH_0",
  "description" : "Josh Peterson and Gary Boyle work through a live PSA licensing dispute, why vendor prices rise every year, and the arithmetic that decides whether an MSP should build its own software instead of paying for it.",
  "duration" : "PT52M35S",
  "embedUrl" : "https://www.youtube.com/embed/TpMpDHIiH_0",
  "name" : "#120 - MSP Software Costs: When Building Your Own Actually Pays | BMK VISION ROUNDTABLE",
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "name" : "Bering McKinley",
    "url" : "https://beringmckinley.com"
  },
  "thumbnailUrl" : "https://img.youtube.com/vi/TpMpDHIiH_0/maxresdefault.jpg",
  "uploadDate" : "2026-08-31T08:00:00-04:00"
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "FAQPage",
  "mainEntity" : [ {
    "@type" : "Question",
    "acceptedAnswer" : {
      "@type" : "Answer",
      "text" : "Only when the tool spend it replaces is large enough to pay for the build. In Gary Boyle's example, an MSP paying about $3,000 a month has roughly $40,000 a year at most to save, which isn't enough to build a real PSA or RMM replacement. MSPs with much larger tool bills have a far stronger case."
    },
    "name" : "Is it worth it for an MSP to build its own software?"
  }, {
    "@type" : "Question",
    "acceptedAnswer" : {
      "@type" : "Answer",
      "text" : "There is no fixed line, but the savings have to cover real development time. Gary's comparison is that $40,000 a year buys about half a year of an $80,000 level two technician, which won't produce a substitute for a full stack. Building is much cheaper than it used to be, yet for a small MSP it can still cost more than it saves."
    },
    "name" : "How much tool spend does an MSP need before building pays off?"
  }, {
    "@type" : "Question",
    "acceptedAnswer" : {
      "@type" : "Answer",
      "text" : "Gary Boyle points to two causes. Low flat monthly fees created a base of customers who barely used the product, so vendors turned to yearly price increases and longer contracts when growth stalled. Labor costs also keep rising with the cost of living, and a vendor that doesn't raise prices is choosing to make less money."
    },
    "name" : "Why do PSA and RMM prices increase every year?"
  }, {
    "@type" : "Question",
    "acceptedAnswer" : {
      "@type" : "Answer",
      "text" : "As Josh Peterson describes it, the client pays a base fee for the tools that monitor and secure their environment, then pays for the support time they actually use. He sees it as more balanced than a flat fee, which can reward doing as little as possible. The tradeoff is that buyers of MSPs tend to value recurring revenue highly."
    },
    "name" : "What is a consumption pricing model for managed services?"
  }, {
    "@type" : "Question",
    "acceptedAnswer" : {
      "@type" : "Answer",
      "text" : "Yes. Gary Boyle says an owner who spends some time with AI coding tools will find they can build real software that solves real problems, even if it isn't perfect. Most platforms have an API, so an MSP can build its own integrations instead of paying for a platform mainly because other software already connects to it."
    },
    "name" : "Can an MSP build its own tools with AI?"
  }, {
    "@type" : "Question",
    "acceptedAnswer" : {
      "@type" : "Answer",
      "text" : "Josh Peterson advises building for yourself first and letting other MSPs adopt it naturally if they ask. Taking a tool to market is a different business that depends on marketing, community, and support more than on the product. Gary Boyle adds that groups of MSPs moving together send a stronger signal to large vendors than one MSP leaving."
    },
    "name" : "Should an MSP sell the software it builds for itself?"
  } ]
}
```